
(photo: SEIU International )
Rep. Dennis Kucinich (D-OH) has written a letter to Attorney General Eric J. Holder expressing concern about an investigation into antiwar activists in Minneapolis and Chicago. The congressman is the latest member of Congress to send Holder a letter on this matter.
In September of last year, the FBI raided seven homes and an antiwar office in the Midwest. Fourteen activists in Illinois, Minnesota and Michigan were handed subpoenas to testify before a grand jury (months later, in December, nine Palestinian solidarity activists in Chicago were given subpoenas). Each of the activists had prior involvement in the Twin Cities Antiwar Committee, the Palestine Solidarity Group, the Colombia Action Network, Students for a Democratic Society and/or the Freedom Road Socialist Organization. They had all participated in a major anti-war march held at the 2008 Republican National Convention.
Kucinich’s letter raises two key questions. One, why was an undercover agent assigned to infiltrate groups planning peaceful protests at the 2008 Republican National Convention?
…As early as April of 2008, with the assignment of an undercover agent to infiltrate the meetings of anti-war groups and individuals who were planning protests and demonstrations at the Republican National Convention in Minneapolis that summer. The introduction of an undercover agent into meetings of anti-war groups would normally be cause for concern in isolation, but it is especially worrisome in the context of other efforts during the previous administration to stifle legitimate anti-war dissent including, as disclosed last month, that the Bush White House had asked the CIA to investigate Juan Cole, a University of Michigan professor who was a strong critic of the Iraq War.
Kucinich asks, “If the justification for that assignment was to determine whether any violent activities were being planned, why was that undercover operation continued after the Convention was over?”
Secondly, Kucinich asks for an explanation for why “small, local groups” are being targeted. He notes the focus of the investigation seems to be that these groups “provided ‘material support or resources’ to foreign terrorist organizations,” which “defies credibility.” He asks Holder why former Attorney General Michael Mukasey, former Homeland Security Director Tom Ridge, former White House security adviser Frances Townsend and former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani, who have publicly expressed “their support for the Mujaheddin-e-Khalq (MEK), are not being targeted for “material support for terrorism.”
The MEK is an “organization that has been on the foreign terrorist list of the State Department since 1997,” Kucinich notes. Each of these individuals spoke at a rally organized by an international group that lobbies for the MEK.
Kucinich highlights how these leaders have been helping to get the MEK removed from the terrorist list:
It has also been reported recently that “the MEK has spent millions of dollars on lobbyists, PR agents and communications firms to build up pressure on Secretary Hillary Clinton to take the group off of the terrorist list.” In [Holder v. Humanitarian Law Project], the Department of Justice, under both your direction and that of Attorney General Mukasey, argued that it was a felony to file an amicus brief on behalf of a foreign terrorist organization, or even to engage in public advocacy on behalf of such an organization, unless that advocacy was totally “independent” of the organization. How do you reconcile those arguments with the total absence of attention paid to lobbying activities in support of the MEK? How do you reconcile that inaction with the apparent overkill that has been directed at the anti-war activists in Minneapolis and Chicago?
Kucinich probably knows the answer but is sending Holder a letter because he wishes to advocate for the activists from a position of power and also hear the answer from Holder himself. This can be presumed because Kucinich asks at one point if the “distinction that justifies the different treatment of these two groups” is simply that one is “composed of prominent people who support the wars conducted by successive administrations” while the other group is “composed of ordinary people who do not.” To anyone following the targeting of these Midwest activists, it certainly seems they are being targeted for their political beliefs and views.
Thus far, Rep. Michael Capuano (D-MA), Rep. John Lewis (D-GA), Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D-IL), Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-IL), Rep. Jim McDermott (D-WA), Rep. David Price (D-NC), Rep. Keith Ellison (D-MN) and Rep. Danny Davis (D-IL) have all sent letters to Attorney General Eric J. Holder. Holder has not publicly addressed the questions raised by congressional leaders or the movement of people around the country who increasingly agree the Justice Department is unfairly targeting activists.
Back in May, Holder was confronted by some of the targeted activists and their supporters when he came to Minnesota to headline youth violence prevention conference and also speak with young adults in the Somali community. He told Tracy Molm, a union organizer with AFSCME Local 3800 whose home was raided, that they would have to “agree to disagree.”
Weeks prior, Rep. Sheila Jackson-Lee (D-TX) invited two activists subpoenaed, Joe Iosbaker and Stephanie Weiner, to write a personal letter that could be submitted into the Congressional record during a House Judiciary Committee debate over reauthorizing provisions of the PATRIOT Act. Their letter provided details on what happened when their home was raided:
On Friday, September 24th, our home was raided by the FBI. We were served a warrant indicating that we were under investigation for providing “material support” to “foreign terrorist organizations.” We were also subpoenaed to a grand jury convened for the purpose of this investigation.
Altogether, 25 FBI agents searched our home, starting at 7:00 a.m. and ending at 6:30 pm. They seized our computers, our cell phones, bank statements and other financial documents. They took note books and files from our lifetimes of political activism. They took artwork off the wall. Our family photos were poured through. We watched as the bedrooms of our two sons were each searched for an hour by three agents wearing blue latex gloves. The agents read one son’s poetry; they sorted through the other son’s t-shirt collection.
As they went through the house, mainly they were interested in any piece of paper with a name and a phone number or email address, what the ACLU’s Mike German has referred to as “associational materials.”
The activists continue to be subject to investigation. In a related case, the FBI is now going after long-time anti-war activist and Chicano leader Carlos Montes.
Over 400 organizations have issued solidarity statements with the targeted activists. Unions representing over 800,000 workers have adopted support resolutions. Numerous street protests have been held since September of last year and petitions continue to net tens of thousands if not hundreds of thousands of signatures.
Support is growing for these targeted activists, and it only increases as the Justice Department refuses to provide and cannot provide a reasonable justification for wrecking the lives of people, who appear to be guilty of exercising their right to assemble, associate and dissent.



61 Comments

I’ll be very interested in hearing the reply that Kucinich receives, if any, Kevin.
What sort of answer or answers have those “others” you mentioned, received to date?
DW
Just Barry and Eric getting the country over that pesky “Vietnam Syndrome.” Barry was too young for the fighting. Eric was in school. Both seem to have forgotten that the New Left suffered through police repression and had originated in the work needed to enable them to be something more than real world step n fetch its. But why should they remember this history. They’re on the make now.
As far as I know (and I included this in my post), Holder has not publicly addressed the questions raised by congressional leaders at all.
Why am I not surprised, Kevin, in the slightest?
Perhaps Holder has answered privately (or secretly)?
DW
“Kucinich Asks Holder Why Justice Department is Investigating Antiwar Activists?
Holder: “We thought no one would notice and besides everyone knows that anti-war activist(the peace movement) is a front for violent extremist. I mean these people chanting about non-violence, seriously who would believe that?”
New American Fascism. Trying to nip any Peace or Freedom (speech,assembly) movement before it really takes off.
Back in ’72, they told me (America) Love it or Leave it. So I did Love it and I Left it.
The Robber Barons are at it again. Not that they ever left off, but they have really crawled out from under their rocks. And now they completely own the government.
America looks even uglier from a distance. How many other expats are on FDL?
I just spoke with one of the activists who says Rep. Schakowsky and maybe a couple others have received responses from Holder but they are all “perfunctory.” They basically are messages asking the congress people to give the DoJ the benefit of the doubt because they wouldn’t do this if it weren’t serious and so on and so forth.
The undercover “Karen Sullivan” (who I tend to think was a police woman due to her use of cover identity as a “lesbian former military member”) initially showed up in late spring 2008 spying on a Code Pink planning meeting (that meeting led to making of giant pink lady puppets that paraded on the first day of the “March on the RNC”). I happened to sit next to “Karen Sullivan” at that meeting and told her about our group that had, for several months, been displaying banners on the footbridges over highways, that it was perfectly legal and that we reached a lot of car traffic. We used big red banners that said “Support the troops—End the War” and “Support the Constitution—End the War”. “Karen” the undercover subsequently showed up (I guess to spy on us!) at our bannering vigils at least 4 or 5 more times that summer. I vaguely remember her asking questions and trying to pry a little but mostly I remember her cover story of being a Lesbian who had a bad experience in the military and who had a young daughter. She kept saying: “I want to get involved and do something.” I would think that she must have been wearing a body recorder or something and there must be some tape recordings of our conservations.
Funny as I would never have expected to have retired from being the Minneapolis FBI legal counsel in 2004 and then only four years later be spied on by a FBI “domestic terrorism” undercover! This type of spying on domestic advocacy groups without a smidgen of suspicion was not legal when I was teaching constitutional law and Attorney General Guidelines to the FBI.
Good for Kucinich and thank you for this piece.
Dennis?
“Rep. Dennis Kucinich (D-OH) has written a letter to Attorney General Eric J. Holder expressing concern about an investigation into antiwar activists in Minneapolis and Chicago. The congressman is the latest member of Congress to send Holder a letter on this matter.”
Holder is going to tell Dennis? “Hey Dennis how many times do we got to kick you in the butt, before you wake up and realize we hate Hippies, Progressives, Liberals “Like U”, Dennis? did we investigate Wall Street? No
Dennis I hope you now know we hate your kind.”
Sincerly Eric Holder ” a reagan lover, bush lover”
Two years later and no DoJ investigations or arrests on Wall Street. Curious. And predictable.
Why isn’t the DOJ investigating ALEC & it’s Federal alums for Bribery, Racketeering, Extortion, Conspiracy & Treason instead? Ask Holder that.
Thank you for joining us to share this information. The whole damned govt is now corrupt. Very, very sad.
It’s an honor to have you here. Thanks for speaking out.
opleaseopleaseopleaseoplease
[cut for format reasons -- ed]
Dennis, give Obama a hello via a serious primary challenge!
Or somebody like you.
10 years in London starting in 1968, but my English husband got a job in the US so we moved back. I’m a disabled senior now & even though I am a US/UK dual-national, moving out again would be physically impossible. Besides, staying here & fighting the Fascists seems worth it.
Why are they investigating anti-war activists? It’s what one would expect from GWB’s 3rd term.
Mahalo, Coleen…! We’re deep inside of Alice’s warren of rabbits…! 8-(
Where did you move to?
Please tell me Germany, which has an excellent system, from what I’ve read.
Many are likely thinking about getting out. The handwriting is clearly on the wall.
Good to see you Coleen.
I was in Russia when I was a teenager in the 70s. And we were told by people there that 1 in 6 people was a spy for the KGB. I see the psyops tactics that the DoD is using on social networking sites to combat the impact of “citizen journalism” (as they call it in their diagrams). It makes you wonder just how extensive the domestic spying networks, private and governmental, have become. I guess it is a hallmark of empires in decline.
Didn’t you hear? Bradley Manning is charged with “aiding the enemy,” but they won’t say who the “enemy” is. Fifty bucks says it’s not the Taliban.
It’s long past the point of disgusting. Anti-democratic authoritarians in the service of a corrupt plutocracy, masquerading of course as “elected” representatives of the “people.”
http://www.buzzmachine.com/2011/07/24/fuckyouwashington/
Thanx for the edit, ed.
thanks to the Patriot Act, we are no longer nor will we ever be a free people ,,,,,
Coleen Rowley !
I appreciate your patriotism.
COINTELPRO 1.0 was a massive national effort to destroy the “Left”. But Martin Luther King Jr. was personally targeted for destruction by cross dressing J Edgar Hoover. King was against the wars and for a safety net. That is a great crime to the Establishment. Same as now. So he was assassinated.
The secret police go after the “inspiring” leaders.
Maybe not free in our lifetime but our country will be free again. Lincoln spoke about “a nation divided against itself cannot hold.” We are very near the breaking point now and things will change. It won’t be easy but the middle class will be there always.
Dennis better watch out or he may recieve a “special” bunch of bananas from Holders friends at Chiquita.
Well then, will the Congress people simply accept this? This is, of course what is said, in essence, to federal judges who too often seem unwilling to muster ANY incredulity. One hopes, however forlornly, that we might have the right to expect far better from Congress people who have, by law and by clear Constututional intent, distinct onligations to the people being “investigated” as well as to truth, itself.
Thank you, Kevin, as always, for your reply and for pushing the envelope that we may be all informed, in depth and in perspective.
DW
*heh* We need to be Israelis now…
Tent protest: Why we march tonight
Tonight, tens of thousands of people will march from the tent camp in Tel Aviv to protest not only the housing prices but the overall discontent and frustration with Israel’s political system. Writer Roni Gelbfish shares six notes on how she found she doesn’t need to be cynical to survive in Israel anymore.
Fancy that, I’m actually praising the Israelis…!
Look forward to more hippie punching, not backward at myriad atrocities.
Good for the marchers. I look forward to the marches in October. We’ll see how engaged Americans are.
I join Jane, Twain, and CTut, in appreciating your comment and your insights.
Thank you, Coleen Rowley.
DW
Yeah, I’m sure Holder is shaking in his boots. How about filing articles of impeachment against Holder, eh, Dennis?
A letter. A letter. A letter. It’s funny how comedy turns to tragedy turns back to comedy. Thanks for the amusement Dennis. Enjoy the veal. Tip your waitress, etc.
The people of the United States, perhaps? (I mean, if they were being honest.
)
Good to know we’ll soon have our Super-Duper Congress! Then Dennis will just have to pipe down. He can be such an annoyance to our all-knowing bipartisan authoritarians!
Holy moly.
What the F is going on in Israel?
THanks for the link.
October 2011
illegitimi non carborundum
Thanks for stopping by. And to those looking for more from Coleen, here’s an interview I did with her back in January.
Last summer’s Washington Post series about “Top Secret America” was well researched and well-written but stopped short of drawing any conclusions. So I just filled in some of the logical and obvious ones: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/coleen-rowley/how-top-secret-america-mi_b_811049.html . I have a good idea that most of what’s going on by the 854,000 analysts, agents, contractors and operatives with “top secret” clearances is simply opportunistic and the result of “green light on” type pressure as this is what drove the McCarthyism and 1960′s domestic security cases predicated upon the threat of communism.
The Oslo terrorism incident should prompt some rethinking since “the bloody mayhem produced by a single Norwegian has no resemblance to the threat perception that has launched a thousand reports, military action across three continents and the massive invasions/occupations of Iraq and Afghanistan. Nor is it in any way related to the hundreds of billions of dollars invested in the West’s intelligence machinery.” (Prof. Michael Brenner at http://english.alarabiya.net/articles/2011/07/24/159037.html)
I know people are really cynical about the value of Kucinich sending a letter or any congress person sending a letter. The activists in Chicago and Minneapolis appreciate any congress person who confronts or at least appears to confront Holder & the Justice Department.
Coleen, should we just be looking at what COINTELPRO did to The New Left back in the late 60s to better understand what is happening here?
It’s really time for another Church Committee, but Obama is just going to try and extend FBI Director Robert Mueller’s term without assessing all the abuses in the past decade.
You’re too resoectful and generous to draw another logical conclusion: they sniff around for marks they can later entrap into attempting to [fill in the] ______________.
I appreciate much of Dennis’ actions. I even saw an article today (Politico or maybe The Hill) report that he had called for Obama’s impeachment in March. Ha! He didn’t actually do that, but he gets credit anyway…. (It was related to the others — Tim Scott & Steve King — who are talking about impeachment in relation to the 14th.)
I’d love to see him bag the district shopping and primary the POTUS.
He really should.
How many trees does an agent have to bark up before he realizes that he’s not even in the right forest.
Rummaging through a kid’s t-shirt drawer?! Get a grip on yourselves already.
Thank you Kevin, and welcome Coleen Rowley.
The Oversight and Review Division of the Office of the Inspector General issued a report dated Sept. 2010. This report was about the FBI investigating domestic groups including Greenpeace, PETA and anti-war groups. Link to the report –
http://www.justice.gov/oig/special/s1009r.pdf
I’d caucus for a Kucinich/Sanders ticket…!
its much harder to leave now than it was then, or even 15 years ago…I wish i would have done so when i had the chance…where, if you dont mind my asking, did you relocate to?
you misunderstand thier purpose. they arent really looking for for anyone who they even remotely suspect of harboring intentions of violence…if they were looking for that they would “infiltrate” gun shows..(by buying the 5 dollar ticket and walking right in)..they are working on a campaign of harrasment abuse and intimidation against those people they identify as leaders or potential leaders of a larger, more active anti-capitalism movement… they arent worried about bombs or bullets. shit! they kinda like bombs and bullets, they are worried about ideas.
This is the report the targeted activists in the Midwest are citing when they argue this investigation is all about targeting them for their political beliefs and not about “material support” for terrorism at all.
And yet, the PATRIOT Act keeps getting extension after extension after extension IN SPITE of the obvious abuses.
I can only conclude the abuses are a feature, NOT a bug, and things are going swimmingly according to the fascist plan.
There are a lot of us. Now working to shed the American half of dual citizenship.
‘Cause we are the Domestic TAHRIRISTS!
Mr Kucinich, please ask Mr Holder if, while his people are in the midwest, they would please go to Wisconsin and start looking into Mr Walker’s voter suppression efforts there?
Could head a few states over to Ohio to check in on the 2004 case of election hacking that Karl Rove and Ken Blackwell were both involved in too.
Walter Mosley gives what is to me a more workable definition of “middle class” than what I think most people are thinking of when they use the term. He says that for a middle class person who loses their job, nothing in their life changes for a year. Those whose lives change drastically within a few weeks after a job loss are working class. See it here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F_VDgbHMV0c
New evidence at Truthout on how the 2004 Ohio election was hacked:
http://www.truth-out.org/new-court-filing-reveals-how-2004-ohio-presidential-election-was-hacked/1311603015
Thanks. That link is exactly why I was suggesting the DoJ should be in Ohio.
Why is the Obama administration acting so much like the Nixon administration? I mean I know that Terrorism is the new Communism. It’s a bugbear to hide behind while you abuse the masses. I just thought Democrats were above all of that.
Kucinich is the only one in Washington with any balls whatsoever. Maybe Al Franken, but that’s about it. What ever happened to patriots like Patrick Henry, who would rather have died than to be molested just to get on a plane? Come to think of it, that’s pretty representative of Americans these days. Ah forget it… you deserve to live in a police state. Enjoy having your balls fondled by blue gloved hands for the rest of your life, pussies.