The Georgia Pardons & Paroles Board is set to execute Troy Davis at 7 pm ET on International Day of Peace. Troy Davis’ attorneys filed a motion for an emergency stay of execution. Lawyers wrote, according to Huffington Post, “No physical evidence has ever conclusively linked Mr. Davis to the murder and significant suspicion rests on the man who implicated Mr. Davis to the police originally.” The Board denied the motion. The defense also wanted a certificate of probable cause to appeal. That was denied too.
Troy Davis tried to get a polygraph or lie detector test before being executed. That request was denied.
In a brief statement published by Dave Zirin at The Nation, Troy Davis declares:
“The struggle for justice doesn’t end with me. This struggle is for all the Troy Davises who came before me and all the ones who will come after me. I’m in good spirits and I’m prayerful and at peace. But I will not stop fighting until I’ve taken my last breath. Georgia is prepared to snuff out the life of an innocent man.”
Nation editors have posted a moving editorial on Troy Davis:
Davis is a black man convicted of killing a white police officer—and in Southern and Northern states alike, this fact alone will trump all others. “Race is everything in this case,” Georgia Congressman John Lewis declared in September 2008, on a day when Davis came within two hours of lethal injection…
…Any support for the death penalty (or attempts to perfect it) amount to an acceptance of a vicious system that cannot be separated from Rick Perry’s Texas—and which is, in fact, exemplified by it. It’s a system that thrives on racism, that condemns the innocent to die. There will not be justice for Troy Davis. But his case has reawakened Americans to a relic of injustice that must be abolished once and for all.
Read the full editorial, “The Killing of Troy Davis,” here.
Six retired corrections officials, including a former Warden who used to work for the Georgia Diagnostic and Classification Prison where he oversaw executions for the state, have written letter asking the state of Georgia to reconsider its decision. If they don’t, they have asked staff that will be carrying out the execution to resist. But this letter likely means nothing to the state of Georgia. There is wide suspicion that tens of thousands of calls have been streaming into the Pardons Board for the last 24 hours and they have in the past hours just taken phones off the hook so they can ignore the world that collectively objects to the atrocity about to be carried out.
As I wrote yesterday, “It is clear that the US will be making international new headlines tomorrow for an execution that may be better described as a state-sanctioned murder given the amount of doubt in the case. It is appalling given how much notoriety this case has that Georgia is actually going to go through this.” The state is going to legally lynch a man.
Watch Democracy Now! broadcast live from the scene.



404 Comments

Thanks for the update, Kevin.
13 Howard University students arrested in front of the White House for Troy Davis
I am so ashamed.
Good for them. I wish I had their guts.
Any way to find out whether they’re getting off with the “parking-ticket-equivalent” fine for protesting or spending the night in the pokey?
If Troy Davis Dies, Save Our Souls
Horrifying. This is our brutal society on display, raw in tooth and claw.
That’s my over-riding feeling today, too. And reading the comments on yesterday’s post only made it worse.
I fervently hope that if WA state pulls anything similar in the future that I’ll have the guts to be outside the prison protesting.
I can’t listen at work. Is that his lawyer speaking now?
Truly. I still cannot believe it is happening.
That’s because they are classified as terrorists now. Like the Wall Street protestors.
Vengeance is mine says the Lord, tough shit replies america we’re the exceptional #1 Devil’s servant.
Those good Ol’ Boys down in the Civil War South are still fighting it. Nobody gonn’ tell THEM what to do with their………
Once again, American shows it’s violent injustice to the whole wide world. Why people want to come here is quite beyond me.
I believe the Livestream has too many viewers because this isn’t really working for me but I can load web pages just fine.
Cut and dried; been said before: “this aint about justice; it’s about revenge.”
When our President has no problem with state-sanctioned murder of those citizens he deems a threat, I suppose we can’t be surprised that the State of Georgia espouses the same viewpoint.
Killing one black man for the crime or another fits Georgia Justice. Whose surprised?
Thou shalt not kill – it doesn’t say “unless” or “except”.
Even if you are not religious, that’s a code to live by.
Like to think i was shocked, but I am not. Obama could step in and commute this sentence at the very least. maybe the SCOTUS will step in at least minute but who knows.
ps riot police outside prison in full force. how can the police stand there and prepare to defend this. guess that is the same question we asked about those in nazi germany. nothing changes and humans will murder others or beat those trying to stop it back, because some prick in power told them to do it.
http://my.firedoglake.com/normanb/2011/09/21/racist-premeditated-murder-pits-kkk-obama-democrats-msnbc-against-pope-carter-tutu-sessions-barr-basic-human-decency/
Ain’t that the truth.
‘cept I think the causality goes the other way: this has been tolerated for so very long in so many parts of the US…it’s not surprising that this so-called Lib’rul president thinks it’s perfectly OK to sanction the assassination of a US citizen abroad–and to do so adamantly and publicly.
They think he’s being executed right now (head of NAACP on Democracy Now.)
I’m not surprised….I’m appalled,shocked,outraged,humiliated and devastated. And I keep whispering deep inside, “Please,please do not kill Troy Davis just because the paperwork’s gone too far to turn around gracefully. Grace is in the turning. Please chose grace.”
Official White House statement: “It is not appropriate for the President to weigh in on specific cases”
I’ll correct: It is not appropriate for the President to take morally courageous positions on specific cases.
oh shit
Seven of the nine eyewitnesses have recanted. Why is this still happening?
Can anyone live-blog the DemocracyNow! feed? I can’t listen at work.
Is it wrong of me to wish that there were more white faces in that crowd?
20K people watching the DN livestream.
coward
A STAY! He’s ALIVE!!!!!
awesome!
OK, that’s it.
It’s not appropriate for me to vote to re-elect this specific PO
TUS.I only expect meaningless rhetoric during presidential election cycles from Obama. Nothing more.
Who’s responsible for the stay?
Everybody on DN is weeping with joy.
SCOTUS?
John Lewis is black. I’m not sure I (or anyone else) is impressed when black politicians claim black murderers are innocent. I’ve seen it too many times to give it any credibility.
Now I do agree the system is tilted against blacks. I just have bigger things to be worried about right now. Such as the slow train wreck that the US has become. We’re looking at the death of a lot more people as a result. Maybe John Lewis can say a word or two about that.
oh no.
Wow. Wow.
Thank you to all the brave, brave folks who kept this in the spotlight and made this last-minute stay possible.
Just. Wow.
Maybe the governor of GA?
I think I see Morgan Freeman in the background?
scooter libby. O is repugnant and tonight he has hit a new low.
He’s a balless coward what did you expect ?
no stay but no execution
what’s uh-oh? did somebody in charge say “psych”?
did somebody re-enact the bit in King Lear where the pardon/stay comes too late?
Troy’s lawyer:
He’s still alive, but stay NOT confirmed. Crowd cheers and announcement potential false positive.
Has the stay been confirmed? MSNBC is still showing Tweety talking and talking and talking. Hasn’t reported a stay yet.
So, we’re just talking about a brief delay?
no stay but no execution – yet
It’s the Obama compromise. A stay of execution won’t be issued but the needle isn’t going to lethally inject him just yet.
CNN isn’t even reporting on it…
reprieve not a stay – could be minutes or hours, hold off for SCOTUS consideration
figures
No, false positive. It is confirmed that he’s still alive.
NEW:
“temporary reprieve from the SCOTUS” CONFIRMED. No idea how long the reprieve is for.
This is horrifying.
but at least they are considering the case
At Fox, they’re reporting that last-minute appeals fail to stop it.
Saying that they expect confirmation of his death in 25-30 minutes.
CNN’s still talking about Israel right now. Ugh. Important topic, but this execution is happening right now.
Watching the DN livestream and listening to the Amnesty International guy, who asks why the U.S. does this: It’s heartbreakingly simple:Americans like to kill. We are a bloodthirsty, violent society. We especially like killing people with darker and/or different skin colors.
“The struggle for justice doesn’t end with me. This struggle is for all the Troy Davises who came before me and all the ones who will come after me. I’m in good spirits and I’m prayerful and at peace. But I will not stop fighting until I’ve taken my last breath. Georgia is prepared to snuff out the life of an innocent man.”
Troy Davis is about to be murdered by the state aperatus. Each person in that process will have his blood on their hands. Each person involved in his murder has the duty to stand up and refuse to do their part. None of the participants is ignorant of the issues in this case, so none may turn away in ignorance saying they did not know. They may turn away, but with full knowledge of their act.
Troy Davis is a pillar of strength. He believes he will be executed but stands tall against the monsters that want his life forfit. We can all learn something from this, and pass it on to others so this will not happen again.
God have mercy on our souls.
I dont think there has been a stay yet.
That’s almost definitely false.
temporary reprieve while SCOTUS considers the case
That’s exactly what they were saying a minute ago, just before they went to commercials.
“So is #troydavis strapped to a gurney waiting to see if the state is going to kill him or not? That’s not justice, that’s sickening torture” @Markfergusonuk
My heart is in my throat.
I know. I’m not even going to try to imagine.
OK, what am I missing?
Why does it seem that just commuting his sentence to something non-lethal isn’t even an option?
I know that wouldn’t solve the over-arching problem of whether or not he’s been wrongly convicted, but that’s a lot easier to address if he isn’t actually, you know, DEAD.
What am I missing?
That’s right. Cruel and unfortunately not unusual.
For Gawd’s sake.
This alone – without any other evidence – should free him.
Obama could stop this. bush had no problems stepping up for scooter. Obama is a fuck. and if troy is murdered tonight we can add his blood to the rest of those murdered in phony wars and drone atatckes, etc that O is covered in
The proper behavior for a President in this case is to send troops to prevent Racist Atrocity. That’s what President Ulysses S. Grant did; that’s what Lyndon B. Johnson did; that’s what even Dwight D. Eisenhower did. This is a temporary stay that may only last for a few minutes. Here’s a strategy through which we can still push for a full stay, or better:
http://my.firedoglake.com/normanb/2011/09/21/racist-premeditated-murder-pits-kkk-obama-democrats-msnbc-against-pope-carter-tutu-sessions-barr-basic-human-decency/
It’s not a federal crime or federal execution.
so civilized. barbaric and that is the truth. we have not changed and the veneer is see through
Empytwheel has a copy of Troy Davis’ emergency petition to the Supreme Court.
legally, I don’t think he can intervene
What are you missing? Nathan Deal, the governor, who has the power to stop the execution doesn’t want some good ole boy to the right of him (is that possible?) to attack him for being “soft on crime”. And none of the other decision-makers so far want to be “seen as soft on crime” either. Hopefully, someone at the Supreme Court has backbone. Or is the delay so that all nine of them will be involved in the decision?
but he could weigh in, with the heavy weight of the Presidency.
Wow. The live-stream had about 5000 viewers when this post went up. Now it’s over 32K. People are interested. (and the sickos watching for enjoyment are probably tuned into FuxNews)
Pete Williams is reporting that the state has a reprieve until the supremes rule.
Almost 35K people watching the Democracy Now livestream now.
Why not. the POTUS has the power to commute and or pardon. bush had no problem with Scooter
all hail Amy Goodman! HAIL!
state case, not federal
Scooter was a federal case.
All the Supremes?
oy!
I’m freaking out, which I tried not to do all day, and I’m not even his mother.
Apparent pause in the process. Awaiting confirmation of what’s happening. + 36,000 viewers on the DemocracyNow.Org live stream. World leaders in executions: US, China, Iran, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia.
Charming company we have there. ick
Also you have aright to a fair trial. if the def has no money and can not afford expert lawyers, experts, etc, how is that fair. Why has nobody challenged the system based on this principle. It is time this BS legal system was challenged.
I figured it’d be something like that.
How many decades since “To Kill a Mockingbird” was published? And no progress at all from “well, he’s black, so if he’s guilty of anything at all, he’s a gotta die…”
And of course, it’s MUCH more important that Mr Deal’s political career live on than some non-white nobody not be wrongly executed.
FWIW:
The cause of the day. Liberals should fight these legally. Failing that, stay off of TV. There is no US conscience, there just isn’t one. Obama certainly doesn’t have one.
Guardian
He could certainly have refrained from that crappy statement that Kevin reported up-thread.
I’d argue that he should have, ‘cept it should make it even more clear to any waverers how thin the difference between Zero and crazy Goodhair Perry actually is.
democracy now viewers now 38,010.
The old 5 to 4. Kennedy mabye no??
Troy Davis may not be a nobody after today, whether he is executed or not. This apparently has gotten world wide attention and the death penalty might be a righteous cause for FDL.
Yeah, well, so’s what that NY attorney general is trying to do about the Mortgage Mess. Doesn’t seem to keep PO
TUS from throwing his weight around on that!Thanks just checked that.
Excerpt fromStatement by Troy read to the National Convention of the Campaign to End the Death Penalty:
No, he could have , on peace day as the Nobel peace prize winner, come out and said he will not execute or support the corrupt, immoral rife with error death penalty.
I guess he doesn’t want to upset his republican brothers.
Actually there was progress from 1970, when Jimmy Carter was elected governor, until 1978 when Zell Miller was elected governor (after the Supremes reinstated the death penalty). And then Reagan began his campaign in Philadelphia MS, spitting on the graves of Goodmans, Schwerner, and Chaney, undid with a speech Charlotte’s exemplary school busing plan, and created the climate for reaction. We are very close to being back to where we were in 1961.
I hope so. I hope the protests and coverage and faces on the TV make it so that an execution WILL NOT make this go away for any of the powers that be. I’m sure that was the original calculation behind denying every possible motion, but I
thinkhope the hard work of so many (who are so much braver than I am) has made that impossible.Scalia was a vote that stayed the execution in Texas. Most unusual.
Did not know that Wow
Guess that’s what I meant. No net progress.
And since I was born in 1968, this is looking very much like actual regression over my lifetime. And I really, really HATE that.
Though I am glad for all who benefited from that all-too-brief window of progress you cite.
I have to leave soon. Catch all y’all FireBaggers much later.
I’ve got 7 candles lit.
Light One Candle, or more.
This is just sadistic. I feel like I’m going to throw up.
Under the Georgia constitution, Governor Nathan Deal has no power to halt the execution. Only the Board or the Georgia Supreme Court can intervene.
So good of Michael Steele to offer his opinion on the situation. Now. Just after he was supposed to die.
Do we know the name of the doctor who’s going to administer the poison? Seems like his name should go viral.
“Who is Troy Davis” and “Democracy Now” are both on the top 10 trends list on twitter right now in the US and worldwide.
Well that sure makes it efficient, doesn’t it?
They use several needles – only one is deadly so that they don’t have to know that they were the one who did it. Cowards. We ought to force them to have public executions if they are going to kill people.
I think they have a set-up where it’s non-MD’s that actually push the button?
Unconfirmed report on DN: the reprieve is for 24 hours to 7 days.
based on that I think he will get a stay. No way the America is going to let the world know, what most suspect, that is barbaric
Well some one or ones have to push the plungers or fill the vials. Let’s find out who they are.
It is what it is, just saying that the Governor couldn’t halt the execution even if he were inclined to do so.
Pretty good video on the case
http://youtu.be/1DGqRFM443Y
A temporary Reprieve is not a Stay.
I want to say it’s a cop that does it?
I do believe the law used to be different, but I lived in Georgia during the time that executions were deemed unconstitutional; the issue never came up. But now, these governors seem like they want to clear out death row for budget reasons. Rick Perry is one of the biggest serial murderers in US history.
I did a search and nothing yet comes up so I don’t know where that man got what he read from local news in Georgia.
I have no idea, but it would certainly be typical for PTB to get low man on totem pole to do their dirty work.
This implies that the prison warden pushes the button, poisons filled by a pharmacist, needle placed by a nurse?
http://gadbuddhaa.tripod.com/thelethalinjectiongurney.htm
Question: Has Davis requested that the bloody shorts found in his house after the crime be DNA tested?
CNN
I’m not seeing it anywhere on channel 11 either.
Dontchyall undastayund? If this heeyu criminal gets a pass, thu entihya Georgya criminul justice system will suffa a stain on it’s reputayshyun. We simply cannot affawd ta let these bleedin hart libruls be manipulatin owa processes like they was Gawd or sumpthin. Tha law is tha law, and tha law says kill ‘im.
Sideshow
Do we know the names of the warden, the pharmacist, the nurse. Let’s go viral. Shaming is one of the tactics the PTB use to control the many. Let’s turn it around.
At the Georgia Diagnostic Classification prison, do they call a lethal injection a “diagnostic test”?
Edit: Sorry, livestream making my comment postings hard to load.
No offense, hotdog, but I’m not really in the mood for your attempt at cleverness. Do you understand that?
Clarence Thomas was born and raised in Pin Point, GA, which is in the same county as Savannah.
Uh, I thought that was an interesting name for a state facility. Chilling.
This is just too much for me.
I can’t handle this, not online anyway.
May God forgive us. Maybe that’s not a fair prayer, condsidering.
I honestly can’t imagine how to get that information (besides maybe the warden.) Good idea, tho.
Agreed, demi. Inappropriate. Prolly not deliberately so.
I don’t agree with that. Let’s shame the ones who deserve it — the ones who allowed this travesty to go forward — not the ones who are doing the jobs they’re hired to do.
Well, it’s hard to deny that the person who physically placed the needle “allowed the travesty to go forward”?
Who do you think is primarily responsible?
Sirens at the DN scene/protest. LOTS of cops. Heading towards prison? Passing protest.
Solidarity protests in Iceland, London, Paris, Germany…others.
Apparently in this case ignorance and indifference carried the day. Just awful.
FOIA?
Carl Humphreys is the warden’s name.
Yeah.
Ugh.
He was being sarcastic, I believe, but the plain truth is that the institutional reluctance of state justice systems to admit they might have made an error is a major and perennial problem in all these (possible) wrongful conviction cases.
You start with the little guys, just like the PTB do. Then, when they cave to the pressure your work your way up the chain of command, unlike what the PTB ever do.
some of the Supremes are CATHOLIC
the Popolo came out AGAINST the execution
just sayin
Democracy Now will be going off air in less than 30 minutes.
you is right as usual
Justice Brandeis sunshine etc
The NY Times article.
one MUST be politically correct/
that’s nice to know!
I apologize. I’m angry too. Should have thought before typing.
That is pretty much the logic though.
parts of this country still replaying the civil war………facepalm
Is it even federally documented?
Parts of parts of the country
Does GA have state FOIA law?
the Pope,and a few BILLION Catholics will damn Scalito etc
http://savannahnow.com/troy-davis/2007-07-20/pope-makes-plea-spare-life-troy-davis
Heh. I live in one of those parts. Never have understood it. Not even when I believed the revisionist history I was taught in school.
well yes…kooks all over da place
Start with the Georgia Parole Board.
me too
a mind is a terrible thing to waste
I know little about the FOIA and execution documentation, honestly.
There are state laws on FOIA. Don’t know if GA has one. NYS does; somewhat diff acronym wh doesn’t come to mind right now.
I think it’s FOIAS down there.
That stands for fuck off its a secret.
hahahahahahahahahahah
15 minutes till the Democracy Now broadcast ends.
Why are reporters not allowed to witness Supreme Court deliberations?
I’m not sure that’s true. It seems that people who are educated and have jobs don’t want to sit on juries. So you end up with a lot of people who have no jobs and no education and a ton of elderly people who many times are afraid of everything – especially scary black men.
That’s one articulate sister Troy has. Good!
“Capital punishment is the most premeditated of murders.”
-Albert Camus, French philosopher
“To take a life when a life has been lost is revenge, not justice.”
-Desmond Tutu
“I have yet to see a death case among the dozen coming to the Supreme Court on eve-of-execution stay applications in which the defendant was well represented at trial… People who are well represented at trial do not get the death penalty.”
-Ruth Bader Ginsburg, U.S. Supreme Court Justice
“The reality is that capital punishment in America is a lottery. It is a punishment that is shaped by the constraints of poverty, race, geography and local politics.”
-Bryan Stevenson
i dont think Sammy,and Antonin will risk eternal damnation from the Pope
somea majority (5)you live Ca,i live in Tn…trust me they are still replaying the Civil War here…but the 2 things are not mutually exclusive
7 of the original jurors in the Davis trial were black, they must not have gotten the memo to be afraid of scary black men.
Check this out — http://s1.proxy04.twitpic.com/photos/large/403920545.jpg
They are preparing for a riot.
WTF? Media not allowed out of the media pen? (weird scene on Democracy Now broadcast.)
well mebbe the Popolo can shake their tiny hearts…crossing fingerz1
And who do you suppose ruled in the jury room? Bet he/she wasn’t black.
I’m in TN, too. Memphis.
crazy country,crazy times………..
howdy partner!
Twitter Trends Map – #troydavis
The whole world is watching.
five! excellent!
I feel so sick.
Murder a probably innocent man and people get a little bent out of shape. Who’d have thought?
I grew up 50 miles south of Memphis. How’s the city doing?
Video from Big Boi – http://www.twitvid.com/L0DGB
Helicopters overhead and sirens all around the Democracy Now broadcast minutes ago.
and tonight Lawrence Brewer was executed in Texas for the 1998 murder of James Byrd Jr
Yee haw?
Shitty, honestly. Only poor people left. The MYPD has gotten better over the last 2-3 years, tho (it was completely infiltrated by gangesters a few years ago.)
Democracy Now continuing to broadcast.
Amy’s extending the broadcast. Not about to end.
My relatives won’t even go to Memphis shopping any more. They are afraid.
Was it a hung jury? Come on, not every black man in prison is the victim of racism.
And yet Byrd’s daughter did want Brewer to die.
“I don’t want him to die because it’s easy,” Mullins said. “All he’s going to do is go to sleep. My father didn’t have that choice to go to sleep.”
Amy Goodman just mentioned that troops are moving in.
“Death Penalty: Stop the execution of Troy Davis” (PaxChristiUSA.Org, Sept. 19, 2011)
Oh, it’s not that bad in terms of danger. There’s violence, but it’s 99.999% crackhead-on crackhead.
Been watching the stream since 7.
The death-penalty quote that always struck me most:
“If a killer warrants death, you must die next, to satisfy that justice.”
- Sophocles, Electra
Of course in Troy’s case, the court system was barely even concerned with actual guilt or innocence.
unbelievable…reallY!
7 recanted,1 dead,the last one a suspect who owned a .38
well goodnight,good pups,concerned with democracy always
Thank you , I did what I could
is the victim’s family’s opinion relevant in death penalty cases?
The Security State of America — ready to deploy on any people who display a human response to atrocities, horrors, injustices or travesties.
Not that I know of outside of public pressure.
..or even appear to be potentially capable of it.
35,500 viewers with lots of attorneys and seasoned human rights/social justice activists on the ground. Goodman is providing spectacular interviews and coverage of all the facets of this. She will keep the cameras there and rolling in Jackson, GA (40 minutes from Atlanta) as long as possible as she takes witnessing seriously.
It seems only pro DP families have a voice in the media
http://youtu.be/0buIIUcyCR0
Troy Davis, and the rest of we the people, are in the gunsights of the hateful . . . . he may die soon, we will die sooner n we want.
It’s class war fueled thru racism and suppression of people color and income and religion on and on.
It’s ugly. N disgusting.
Bless Troy Davis and his efforts and his team;s efforts.
SOmeday, moral compunction trumps the hand of power.
Guess it’s not in MY lifetime tho . . .
Yep, that’s the analogy.
Obama cannot commute, states rights issue, you’ve mounted that beast a few times before, other’s have pointed out yer WRONG, and yet you continue to whip the horses eyes.
What’s WITH you?
pic:
http://twitpic.com/6ohwik/full
WTF?
Go sell that shit to the Klan n get off my corner.
Get The HAYALL Off My Corner.>
Unconfirmed:
Excellent! Thanks!
Seriously.
Yeah, that and other essential details have been pointed to here many times in the past fed days, but she goes on and on factually challenged and just plain WRONG.
Much to my surprise, delight and amazement Troy Davis is still alive. God willing he will remain so.
Is Democracy Now’s livestream down?
It’s backish…glitchy.
Map of tweets on Troy Davis
The guy that just spoke on DN’s livestream is a BADASS.
Amy says massive traffic is disrupting website/livestream.
Amy “Be patient.”
Erm, is there any instance in history where this happened?
IANAL, but them damned legal beagles on FDL have made an impression on me in some of these regards . . .
Sound of helicopters overhead on DN’s broadcast again.
Troy Davis and Democracy Now have both been in the top 10 twitter trends globally and in the US tonight, often at the same time.
One of the most spectacular presentations I’ve ever seen about the true nature of the thinking, attitudes, actions and habits of killing was depicted in “Unforgiven.”
wow, impressive
idk – shouldn’t preclude him from speaking up.
Rainbow Medical has a contract with the state of Georgia for executions, among other things. I found it through google on the intertubes.
1) He don’t HAVE the constitutional authority in this case, it’s states rights issues and do YOU want to revive the Civil War more n it already is?
2) He won’t morally take a public stance cuz it would fuck with his political campaign. If he DID take a public stance it would NOT change my NOT voting for him, and I think he KNOWS he’s lost his base.
He ain’t gonna get involved and if he does for cause of Troy Davis, I’ll incredibly surprised.
Rafe? BGR?
Larue here . . .
Thanks for that tidbit, did not know that.
AMY: (paraphrased) “As you saw earlier, I can’t leave this little media pen without getting booted from the scene alltogether. Weird.”
Interviewee: “The riot police are scary. We’re all surrounded by them, and their face shields are down, shields are up.”
“Evidence sent to Georgia Medical Board shows Dr. Musso and CorrectHealth, LLC, illegally imported and distributed drugs to be used in executions” … “Southern Center for Human Rights Files Complaint Seeking Revocation of Dr. Carlo Musso’s Medical License” (SCHR.Org, documents linked, no dates shown).
SCHR.Org News
Democracy Now’s livestream is down again?
Rafe, if that’s you . . . Tanbark comments here too!
*G*
Thanks for the link. Amy was just interviewing the woman from the Georgia anti-death penalty group who pointed that out. They had to change the drug to a different one.
Amy’s producer said [paraphrased], “on one side you have a phalanx of riot police, and on the other you have a crowd of people quietly holding candles [or lights]. You have to wonder what they are afraid of.”
A great movie
Sacto, here.
Indeed.
Democracy Now livestream is back!
Oh, I just realized I heard it as Georgia corrections imported the drug and that you’re saying the head of Rainbow Medical was the one importing the drug.
Given the history of the Catholic Church and its armies, and it’s lawyers these days, I would NOT spit on a nickel n toss it further than my feet that them there 5′s religion means squat in issues like this.
It sure as hayall hasn’t yet since Bush’s appointments.
This is one of the meanest, blood thirsty, no coverage of issues progressive, n nastiest Supreme’s ever.
So, was he guilty or not? I don’t want to have to read a whole linky for an initial thot . . . YOUR take? Please? Thanks . . .
Um, well, yes they are for the most part.
It starts with profiling on the street.
Incarceration.
Lack of legal defense funds.
Longer sentencing than whites.
N spirals down from there.
Yeah, it’s you Rafe, ain’t it!
*G*
Say, what happened to yer BGR radio thing? I was lookin for it and it was gone I think?
I just have been reading the post at your link. As I thought I heard on Democracy Now, Georgia corrections did get their supply of the drug directly from the company in London. Musso also imported it and distributed it to two states. Musso didn’t have state or federal licenses to import it as it’s a controlled substance.
Still over 30K people watching the Democracy Now livestream.
About the lethal injection drugs
Steven Colbert talks about Cali’s search for the death drugs. Here’s where the info came from
Ben Jealous of the NAACP is my new hero.
I humbly suggest it’s one of the best movies ever . . .
N that covers a lot of time and silver screens.
Indeed.
Supreme Court refuses the stay, will not block the execution
“Supreme court refusing to stay the execution of Troy Davis”
AP, basically confirmed.
Please be wrong, AP.
According to AP, reported by Amy, the Supreme Court has declined to stay the execution.
Stay denied per Supremes. Reported on Ed show.
Please, please be wrong, AP.
Amnesty International confirms.
I’m crying.
OMG.
OMG.
Confirmed by Renee F, Democracy Now producer.
Damn!
One, constitutional issues.
Two, political liability if he does one way or another.
He’s a playah, he allus plays for the rich.
He sits this one out, despite his ethnicity, the prejudices against his ethnicity and well, any signs of a heart for humans beyond serving the overlords.
N if I haven’t said it or shown it, this whole thing, and Obama, sickens me to death.
I’m disgusted with the nation, country, and our place on the planet.
Felt that way for a decade or so, or more, hell, felt that way when I was protesting Vietnam in hi school in ’67-71. . . . . LeSigh.
Have NO idea why I thought it had all gotten better . . . but I thot I’d work forever too . . . funny ’bout that too . . .
Bless Troy Davis.
“Troy Davis will be given a sedative to calm him”
This can’t be real.
Me too!
Yeah, the film actually does show the antidote for that particular self-administered poison. A great film indeed and, IMO, best seen on a big screen. Fortunately there’s a passel of great films.
This can’t be real. Holy shit.
everyone on here is outraged.
and yet we wait for the scotus to make it better
just like we wait for the potus to make it better on all kinds of issues
just like we wait for congress to make it better on all kinds of issues
we know the system is corrupt
we know even if there is a stay it is still corrupt
and yet we place all our power in hope that said corruption will do the right thing tonight. A phyricc victory ( sorry for the spelling) but until we storm the powers of corruption, we have achieved nothing
Troy’s fate tonight is because we have allowed this corruption to exist, and even if he is granted a stay, the fact is we allow such corrupt systems to decide that, shows we are all just slaves to the system. A system that can kill, literally, financially, or otherwise, and yet we demand that those that destroy us show mercy this one time.
If they do we applaud. When will we awake from this nightmare that rests entirely on our support?
MSNBC reporting 20 to 30 minutes until execution.
Damn, last few posts would suggest Mr. Davis WILL die in GA.
A pox on them for doing so, all them fat white n sweaty fucks.
RAGE. SADNESS and RAGE.
N a pox on the fat, white sweaty dudes on the SCOTUS, who have enabled the end of our democracy as surely as Ceaser’s Generals and Senators ended Rome’s.
Bless Troy Davis.
The image of riot police lined up to protect Georgia’s right to kill people is stark and shocking.
((((((Group howls and hugs!)))))
“There’s a time when the operation of the machine becomes so odious—makes you so sick at heart—that you can’t take part. You can’t even passively take part. And you’ve got to put your bodies upon the gears and upon the wheels, upon the levers, upon all the apparatus, and you’ve got to make it stop. And you’ve got to indicate to the people who run it, to the people who own it, that unless you’re free, the machine will be prevented from working at all.”
and the thin ones and the black ones and the female ones. there was no dissent.
I’m sobbing. This is just so fucked up.
This is new. Even in the South. Paranoia over a vigil, for chrissake.
The security state has become completely unhinged.
RAGE. RAGE. RAGE.
It’s WRONG.
RAGE.
Now? Now they’re going to give him a sedative? What about the last 2 hours and how many minuets?
Good God!
I’ll be part of that.
right blame scotus which is corrupt and what have you done to expose it and all the other corruption? read my post @ 276 we are all complicit in this
Cry those tears and know we are complicit in this. We have allowed this system to exist.
welcome, sister! the tears are flowing.
nazi germany paid by us the taxpayer. we all own this. accept that and maybe then you will wake up
shut the fuck up. can you let people grieve now? spew your complicit stew tomorrow or next week.
This is probably not a good time to go postal on nice people here.
Larue’s one of the good guys.
Everyone’s upset. Please, knock it off.
“Too bad, so sad” for Troy Davis over these last few hours.
RAGE.
Much nicer delivery than mine. You nice lady!
WHAT am I supposed to DO? I live in poverty in North Memphis. My phone, electricity, and internet gets cut off EVERY month. WTF am I supposed to do?
Well, YOU’RE complicit. You are not responsible for anyone but yourself, so don’t go around trying to flagellate others who clearly are anti-death penalty and see the racism inherent in the legal process.
Why don’t you just go sit down and contemplate your own guilt. Your self-righteousness is ridiculous.
not going postal, just telling the truth. Troy may die tonight because we the people have allowed the BS, so called justice system to decide.
and what have you done to stop anything?? like me probably F all. at least I am honest
I just wished that I coulda said it like you did.
Well. That’s all I have to say.
And, shit! Taking names. Not like I didn’t already have an opinion.
Well, goodie two-shoes for you.
Here’s your cookie.
Now STFU.
Please know that you are not the only one with the ability for compassion and truth. Please.
Actually it’s homegrown. There have been very few times in the history of this country that innocent people were not rashly executed by counties and states. Taxpayers have paid for this for 400 years. For a very brief period we succeeded in stopping the madness. It came back. You probably are not old enough to remember the name Caryl Chessman. He was the reason that a major movement to end capital punishment gained ground in the 1960s leading to the Supreme Court’s ruling in 1972 that it was cruel and unusual punishment, and thus unconstitutional. And we got complacent or scared of “crime”. And got steamrollered back into capital punishment in all but a handful of states by a new Supreme Court and pandering state legislators. And then some states privatized some aspects of it.
I am awake. I am very much awake. Now, tell me what you think your “you” should do?
Troy WILL , not “might” die tonight.
HOW THE HELL are people like me, 37% of the population, living in poverty responsible???
Are you feeling guilty that you’re complicit? What are you feeling?
For those bemoaning this result, you might want to consider donating to or otherwise supporting the Innocence Project, which has been fighting and frequently successfully overturning wrongful verdicts for 20 years. I interned with the co-founder, Barry Scheck, he is the real deal, and I am so proud of having even that tenuous association with the great work they do. Nobody has been more effective in this area.
Society and the family of a MURDERED peace officer will finally get some justice tonight. Don’t believe everything you read and hear from the mainstream media. Troy Davis got his fair day in court, the witnesses against him were cross-examined by his defense, and a supreme court-ordered re-hearing was held. In every instance he was judged GUILTY and deserves what awaits him in just a few minutes.
I don’t relish anyone’s death, but the sentence carried out tonight, however long-delayed, is just and fair.
Looks like we’re hearing from the Georgia State Department of Corrections.
NationalActionNetwork.net and chapters.
I don’t know any folks in your area but I think you might be in good company here:
Memphis, TN
Contact: Gregory Grant, President
Alonzo Grant III, EVP
Tel: 901-527-1776
Website: http://www.nanmemphistn.org
Realitychecker @ 308: InnocenceProject.Org
Thanks for pointing us in that direction.
Oh.
Damn.
It’s like the 50′s n 60′s again hoss . . . there sure were horrid policin tactics then, before Fed Guard was called in . . . busing and education.
Perhaps this is the wave where it gets better . . . (not likely IMHO).
Lady, yer off the charts and I can’t measure you yer bouncing all over.
But so far, you been corrected a NUMBER of times about the President’s power WRT this sitch, and you continue to say the same things.
So, I guess I’ll just let ya rant all ya want, and not reply no mo.
You ain’t gettin the message yer bein sent.
The execution is apparently beginning.
Also support:
Amnesty International
http://www.amnesty.org/en/death-penalty
Human Rights Watch
http://www.hrw.org/en/united-states/us-program/excessive-punishment-and-restrictions
*G*
Exactly.
And Amnesty International chapters coordinate with other local groups to end capital punishment through legislation and through letter-writing campaigns about particular cases. Likely a lot of those overseas tweets came from people who had written government officials in Georgia and the US on behalf of Troy Davis’s case.
And use your personal networks of friends, family, neighbors, and co-workers to build a movement to stop capital punishment.
But for now, grieve. For the loss that Troy Davis’s family has, for the failure of so many people to get other people (who just happen to be officials in government) to act as human beings instead as part of a machine, for the continuing lost innocence we all feel for a government that so many taught us was just and moral, for yet another loss of our freedom to actually redress grievances through speech and assembly, and for a culture that has increasingly gone mad.
Grotesque ignorance.
Relative to the question of state-sanctioned killing, I don’t know how much the particulars of the case matter. I’m not saying that guilt or innocence don’t matter; I’m saying that it’s almost as if you either take pleasure from the finality of the executions, or you’re degraded and shamed by them…which is my feeling.
I’m glad that this case is drawing such attention. Regardless of the outcome (and I dearly hope that this does not go forward) it might be the first resurgence of a progressive ethic, and that it comes in the face of Barack Obama’s practically compulsive sellout of us, is doubly heartening.
Rafe, IS that you? If it is, welcome to FDL.
) As a conservative you may get dog-piled on a bit (
) ) but for letting us rock with all those tens of thousands of unmoderated posts at Bluegrass Rules, i WILL defend your right to be here, as long as I can type.
If this is you, know that across any political differences, I count you a friend. Someone once posted that I should be ashamed of myself for stirring up the pot at BGR. I told them:
“Ashamed! Hell, I’m proud of ALL the hell that we’ve raised over here…left, right, middle.”
EVERYbody got a chance to “say”, and boy-howdy, did we evermore say.
)
Did you catch TBogg’s thread about Nader and Palin? Hot damn, it was nebbout straight off the “Porch”.
)
Rage RAGE RAGE!
Rage at the people doing this, and rage at those who blame ME!!!
My one little tiny bit of power that I have is access to the internet (and even that gets cut off every month.)
My god, I wish I was religious/superstitious again. I used to be Christian. Oh, to be able to believe that I was an operative of a higher power again.
Atheism is so desolate sometimes.
It all depends on how willing people are to go up against police dogs and fire hoses.
Don’t hold it against them. They have been fed a pack of lies about these so-called recanted testimonies when in fact not one of them is actually conversant with the facts of the case. They grasp for any supposed miscarriage of justice, however ephemeral and imagined, as proof that the death penalty should be abolished.
(((((Athena))))))
Time of death is 11:08
Nah, that’s just some dumb cracker tawkin proggy n failin.
Spill on #309 mods . . .
No just honest. we have a F up system that our tax dollars pay for. So yes, I have helped this get this far
Sorry, dude, I think you have the wrong Rafe; I’ve never visited the site you mentioned.
THIS has been an interesting thread though.
I believe it should be abolished.
Oh, maybe I wasn’t clear. Grotesque ignorance on your part.
Honest isn’t a feeling. Your thoughts and opinions aren’t feelings. I’m asking what you are feeling.
Tan!
*G*
Sweet!
Good times!
Dear Happy and Insect; I don’t need for Davis to be innocent for this grotesque parody of “justice” to not take place. I know it’s wrong in my mind and in my heart. I’m genuinely sorry that you guys think it’s right.
*bowshead*
How come you responded to him n not me?
I feel, slighted . . . lmao.
Did anyone hear Troy’s last words?
Tanbark, I don’t agree with that person!!!!!!! See my last comment.
Rafe, thanks for responding, and, my 2c, the welcome still stands. I don’t think anyone on here will threaten you or talk shit about your ancestry, or anything like that. We ARE moderated, and I think that’s to the good.
Talk to you again.
Sorry, when was that? I’ve only been checking in from time to time to get updates on the situation, maybe scroll up a few comments to see what was said.
Sara Totonchi, H. Lee Sarokin Executive Director of SCHR.Org just spoke with Amy Goodman.
Those fuckers.
He said he didn’t do it.
“I did not kill your son, father, or brother.”
“He maintained his innocence until the very end.”
You don’t know what you’re talking about.
“Insect; sorry! Sometimes, when the thread is movin’ like the Fireball Mail, I lose track of who said what. I’ll pay more attention.
N with that, I’m outta here . . . a horrid ending to a horrid spectacle, and a human’s life.
I still wanna believe as a species we’re better n this, but I’m fully convinced (to you peace makers) we have to fight and risk getting hurt or killed to beat this beast.
Why do I believe this?
Cuz history proves. Even Ghandi’s followers died at the hands of the oppressors.
Fight, or die not fighting, you die any ways . . . n they WILL kill you if you let them without fighting.
Best to all.
Religion doesn’t make it any less desolate, athena1. It just gives a lot of imaginative words for “desolate”.
Dude, you are parroting a bunch of BS that has been perpetuated by anti-death penalty cabals who are using the media to throw suspicion on capital punishment. Troy Davis got plenty of chances to present evidence of his innocence, the “recanted” testimonies were heard in a re-hearing, and in every case he was found guilty. Twenty years and not a single ruling that he was innocent or that the facts heard in the case were flawed. Not. A. Single. Ruling.
Justice delayed is justice denied. At 11:08 this evening, justice was served.
No problem. I’ve lurked FDL for years though I’ve only recently left my mark in the comments, though apparently I could be a paid stooge for the Koch Brothers.
The only one who really got on my case was Norsk Flamethrower or some name like that, cussed me a bluestreak that curled my hair, everyone else has been cool. Beats the heck out of trying to talk to anyone at ThinkProgress or Redstate.
I will say this one last time. Stop blaming georgia, stop blaming the system, we have all paid into it, we have all given it its money, tonight Troy, tomorrow some drone attack that kills a family in pakistan.
Our money, our always expecting xys to do the right thing, when we know they are corrupt as shit. Our murder, be it tonight or tomorrow. And the fact we showed up at the hour before midnight to change that means nothing. even if he get a stay where were we when this system allowed him to be convicted. where were we when we allowed our govt to use 9/11 to start unjust wars, where were we when………….
the list goes on
Right, you jackass. They are “using the media.” Haven’t you noticed that the media is barely covering this?? Jesus.
11:08
As John Donne said, I am diminished. I think we all are.
Strapped to a gurney, addressing the victim’s family, “I did not have a gun. I didn’t do it. I didn’t kill your son or brother or father.”
He didn’t take the ativan.
Oh, Sweetie.
Keep on.
Troll. Ignore.
Please enlighten me but with facts of the case that are not something you just heard in the media. You apparently are a legal practitioner, so lay on, McDuff. Where did the courts err? Which SPECIFIC recantation should have been found sufficient to overturn his sentence? Which witness actually said his or her testimony was in error, and in a sworn affidavit has admitted to lying on the stand?
I’m waiting.
thank god, it’s finally the last time.
i guess you’re not planning to answer my questions about what you are feeling.
Norske does throw some flame. But I gotta say, his rant-level is nothing compared with what a liberal will get if he shows up at Late German Fascists.
sorry athena I know you are fighting the good fight. not sure what i can say. all I know is it comes down to money and until we start starving the beast, we will have no chance of changing J shit
I wonder why the Board didn’t take Davis up on the offer to be polygraphed, would a poly still be inadmissible even now?
Bwaaaaa! Doesn’t matter WHO shows up at LGF, they better toe the current company line or it’s game over; that place is industrial strength crazy.
Goodnight folks. See you manana.
Diverse voices are welcome here, if they are rational and/or civilized. Welcome.
Really? Didn’t I see posts up above about all the TV crews at the prison? It’s been on every station down here in the great state of Georgia for the past week. What are you usng as your news sources? AOL? Myspace? TeenBeat magazine?
He’s dead now. How does admission in court apply?
Take responsibility that you are part of what happens tonight. you pay into the system. just at a lower level than the bankers, but a way higher level than troy
(((Greenie))
Reaching out into the darkness…
Goodnight.
Probably wouldn’t register on the polygraph anyway.
I saw an earlier post that said Davis offered to be polygraphed earlier in the day, I was wondering why he wasn’t taken up on it.
Appreciated.
You’ve seen the faces, names and organizations of those who will not stop working for peace, justice and equality. Are you saying you refuse to join with them?
I get paid to do this kind of analysis for people. You can get it for free at the Innocence Project website. How to give you a true sense of the ultra-high standards of process that a capital case is supposed to uphold? Maybe put yourself thru three years of law school. Now, please shut up until you educate yourself.
Your brain waves have nothing to do with this.
If you think merely withholding our taxes will bring this system down, you are truly a dreamer. But, keep that anger alive, it may come in useful someday, maybe soon.
No i do not think that. we need to reform our monetary system just for starters, but what do you offer? hmm
elaborate who are these organizations, and what have they achieved.
Or, tune in to MSNBC right now, and listen to Barry Scheck explain about, particularly, the ballistic evidence that was relied on to show motive.
#380 was meant to be addressed to you.
G’nite, greenwarrior. A better day tomorrow.
and before you do, I was in afghanistan right after we invaded, and i saw them all, and i saw there need for money, and I saw there pyricc wins, (sorry spelling) on their website and I witnessed the truth
My guess, if he passed, not admissible evidence. If he failed, would call into question the infallibility of the system to get it right. They are always very defensive about protecting their image for infallibility.
happytosharebut-we really don’t want any of your shit anyway- has an unwavering faith in a criminal justice system that gives us such jewels as this guy: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2011/02/18/national/main20033443.shtml
“Fry ‘em! Oops. Sorry, wrong guy. My bad. hahahahahaha”
You’ve already been given the names of some of those organizations.
You’re out of touch right now. I’m sorry for your pain, but you have upset people here. For no reason that I can figure.
Get some rest and try again tomorrow. That’s the best advice I can offer.
First taxes, now monetary system. We have no influence over either. It will take massive civil disobedience, massive, or armed resistance. Either may fail and get you killed, though. How angry are you? Don’t say anything incriminating.
It’s all documented here. Now I have to ask, who pays you to come here and attempt to sow hopelessness, doubt and discord?
I would have thought then that the defense team might have pulled out the remaining stops, what was left of them anyway. I’m going on a basic outline of the case here, but I believe there was a bloody pair of shorts found in Davis’ house that were never used in the trial because they were taken without a search warrant.
Wouldn’t the defense be able to say “Hold on, let’s DNA test those shorts” now that the endgame is here? Seems like crucial evidence to me, or is there something I’m missing?
Barry Schenk’s group has gotten innocent prisoners on death row released and pardoned. Lawyers have then sued the states for the failure of justice.
Any number of state anti-capital punishment groups have fought for decades against the conservative drive to have an unaccountable death penalty. They have succeeded in pushing back capital punishment in the Great Lakes states and some states in New England. And have effectively pressured the state of Kansas not to conduct an execution.
But there are states with hard right legislatures and governors that have become execution mills. The worst is Texas under Rick Perry.
Fighting political battles is difficult and requires a lot of people to participate, often beyond their comfort zones in persuading their personal networks to support them in what they do. That often means converting people who are pro-death penalty to anti-death penalty.
The ability of these groups to do what they do is only as good as the local people working on their local issues. Some are better than others. Some have more difficult situations than others. Get involved where you are and see what you can help accomplish.
How come no one has asked why it took him 15 minutes to die?
I can’t be the only one who has had to euthanize a pet and it took seconds, a minute tops.
The question within your question is a good one, but I think the answer to the superficial one is that a lot of us are kind of in shock.
Jeez, I just wrote you a long response, and it got disappeared before I could Submit it. Probably cuz a new post just got added, that happens. I’m exhausted. Check Innocence Project website, or Google, “Troy Davis bloody shorts.” I’m sure you’ll get an answer to that question. Sorry. Gotta get some sleep, my eyes are going funny.
Good night, Firepups. Dream of better days ahead.
Hope so, rc.
Simply have to watch this video.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rNQRfBAzSzo
So, there are “ultra-high standards of process that a capital case is supposed to uphold”? Great! So we have over twenty+ years followed that proces to tne nth degree and still this dirtbag was found guilty. That means the system worked, and I can sleep better at night. I appreciate all that schoolin’ you went through to confirm that Troy Davis got what he deserved.
“Buddy you’re a boy make a big noise
Playin’ in the street gonna be a big man some day
You got mud on yo’ face
You big disgrace
Kickin’ your can all over the place”
Get a clue to what you’re talking about. You’ve got to mis-use lyrics from a great artist whose boots you aren’t fit to shine to make your primitive jeer. Pathetic.
None are more certain than the wilfully ignorant. That never varies. Thus endeth the lesson.
Don’t be too hard on yourself. You’re not willfully ignorant. You are just trying to use this case to bolster your hatred for the death penalty.
And you used the lyrics from a different song. Snuff said.
Cheers. I’m out.
Note the difference between “used” and “mis-use.”
Also note the difference between cheers and jeers. The former is for happy occasions, the latter is for frothing at the mouth, gang-think.
Don’t you ever get tired of being wrong?
Dispute this d-bag. Here are actual facts.
After a two-week trial with 34 witnesses for the state and six witnesses for the defense, the jury of seven blacks and five whites took less than two hours to convict Davis of Officer Mark MacPhail’s murder, as well as various other crimes.
Davis pulled out a gun and shot two strangers in public. What “physical evidence” were they expecting? No houses were broken into, no cars stolen, no rapes or fistfights accompanied the shootings. Where exactly would you look for DNA? And to prove what?
I suppose it would be nice if the shell casings from both shootings that night matched. Oh wait — they did. That’s “physical evidence.”
It’s true that the bulk of the evidence against Davis was eyewitness testimony. That tends to happen when you shoot someone in a busy Burger King parking lot.
Eyewitness testimony, like all evidence tending to show guilt, has gotten a bad name recently, but the “eyewitness” testimony in this case did not consist simply of strangers trying to distinguish one tall black man from another. For one thing, several of the eyewitnesses knew Davis personally.
The bulk of the eyewitness testimony established the following:
Two tall, young black men were harassing a vagrant in the Burger King parking lot, one in a yellow shirt and the other in a white Batman shirt. The one in the white shirt used a brown revolver to pistol-whip the vagrant. When a cop yelled at them to stop, the man in the white shirt ran, then wheeled around and shot the cop, walked over to his body and shot him again, smiling.
Some eyewitnesses described the shooter as wearing a white shirt, some said it was a white shirt with writing, and some identified it specifically as a white Batman shirt. Not one witness said the man in the yellow shirt pistol-whipped the vagrant or shot the cop.
Several of Davis’ friends testified — without recantation — that he was the one in a white shirt. Several eyewitnesses, both acquaintances and strangers, specifically identified Davis as the one who shot Officer MacPhail.
Now the media claim that seven of the nine witnesses against Davis at trial have recanted.
First of all, the state presented 34 witnesses against Davis — not nine — which should give you some idea of how punctilious the media are about their facts in death penalty cases.
Among the witnesses who did not recant a word of their testimony against Davis were three members of the Air Force, who saw the shooting from their van in the Burger King drive-in lane. The airman who saw events clearly enough to positively identify Davis as the shooter explained on cross-examination, “You don’t forget someone that stands over and shoots someone.”
Recanted testimony is the least believable evidence since it proves only that defense lawyers managed to pressure some witnesses to alter their testimony, conveniently after the trial has ended. Even criminal lobbyist Justice William Brennan ridiculed post-trial recantations.
Three recantations were from friends of Davis, making minor or completely unbelievable modifications to their trial testimony. For example, one said he was no longer sure he saw Davis shoot the cop, even though he was five feet away at the time. His remaining testimony still implicated Davis.
One alleged recantation, from the vagrant’s girlfriend (since deceased), wasn’t a recantation at all, but rather reiterated all relevant parts of her trial testimony, which included a direct identification of Davis as the shooter.
Only two of the seven alleged “recantations” (out of 34 witnesses) actually recanted anything of value — and those two affidavits were discounted by the court because Davis refused to allow the affiants to testify at the post-trial evidentiary hearing, even though one was seated right outside the courtroom, waiting to appear.
The court specifically warned Davis that his refusal to call his only two genuinely recanting witnesses would make their affidavits worthless. But Davis still refused to call them — suggesting, as the court said, that their lawyer-drafted affidavits would not have held up under cross-examination.
With death penalty opponents so fixated on Davis’ race — he’s black — it ought to be noted that all the above witnesses are themselves African-American. The first man Davis shot in the car that night was African-American.