According to an October 1 article at Prisoner Hunger Strike Solidarity (PHSS), the Federal receiver’s office has indicated that “nearly 12,000 prisoners were on hunger strike, including California prisoners who are housed in out of state prisons in Arizona, Mississippi and Oklahoma.”
This is the second hunger strike in less than four months, with prisoners at the Supermax Pelican Bay Prison and other California state prisons protesting the use of long-term solitary confinement, in addition to four other main demands, including provision of adequate and nutritious food, an end to administrative abuses (such as group punishments), and expansion, and in some cases provision, of “Constructive Programming and Privileges for Indefinite SHU Status Inmates.”
But besides an end to state-sanctioned isolation, which amounts to torture, the most salient demand is an end to the hated “debriefing” system, which places inmates in solitary if prison officials determine they are “gang members.” As I noted in an article last July, determination of “gang” status includes “acquisition or exchange of personal or state property amounting to more than $50…. tattooing or possession of tattoo paraphenalia…. possession of $5 or more without authorization…. [and] refusal to work or participate in a program as assigned,” among others. Indeed, even refusal to submit to “debriefing,” i.e., interrogation of prisoners to get them to “snitch,” or give names of other “gang” members, is reason to label someone a gang member and put them in solitary indefinitely. The prisoners call this “snitch, parole, or die.”
Both isolation and forced confessions are illegal forms of incarceration. The 2006 Commission on Safety and Abuse in America’s Prisons, co-chaired by former Chief Judge of U.S. Court of Appeals, Third Circuit, John Gibbons and former Attorney General Nicholas de B. Katzenbach, called for an end to isolation in U.S. prisons. (See summary of findings and recommendations, PDF.)
A Fight for Dignity, Justice, and Humanity
California prisons are a stinking mess, a scandal of gigantic proportions. The health care component of the California prison system has been in federal receivership for years because of the awful, insufficient care provided to the sick and mentally ill. As reported in a McClatchy article last May, the U.S. Supreme Court “cited ‘serious constitutional violations’ in California’s overcrowded prisons and ordered the state to abide by aggressive plans to fix the problem.” The court rejected state pleas to put off the necessary changes, and ordered the prison system to lower its population by approximately 37,000. (A plan to implement the changes is meeting some skepticism.)
According to the McClatchy article:
One hundred and twelve California prison inmates died unnecessarily because of inadequate medical care in 2008 and 2009, analysts found. Acutely ill patients have been held in “cages, supply closets and laundry rooms” because of overcrowding, investigators found. Suicides by California inmates have been double the national average.
No wonder the prisoners’ hunger strike is gaining so much support in California prisons, where inmates are held like animals. The overcrowding is largely due to long-time incarceration for drug charges, including simple possession, and California’s onerous Three Strikes law.
The prisoners have indicated they will conduct “rolling” hunger strikes, allowing prisoners to come off strike to regain their strength. They indicated they have resumed their strike after changes promised after the July hunger strike by the California Department of Corrections & Rehabilitation (CDCR) failed to materialize, in particular “demands related to solitary confinement and gang validation.”
Meanwhile, CDCR has indicated they will punish strikers. Two attorneys representing prisoners in mediation talks with the CDCR have been “banned from all prisons pending an investigation into whether or not they had ‘jeopardized the safety and security of CDCR’ institutions.”
According to an article at the PHSS website, “The CDCR has delivered memos to prisoners at each state prison threatening that any participation or support for the hunger strike will result in disciplinary actions, such as placement in Ad-Seg/ASU [Administrative Segregation Unit] or SHUs [Security Housing Units] (for prisoners currently in General Population), increased destructive cell searches, removal of canteen items, and worse. We know that a number of prisoners lost their jobs as added punishment for supporting the strike in July.”
International Support
The renewed strike has gotten support from Palestinian hunger strikers protesting the use of isolation in the imprisonment of Palestinian leaders such as Ahmad Sa’adat. The use of isolation to punish and break prisoners is not limited to California or U.S. prisons, but cases involving American prisoners have made the news in recent months, including the incarceration of Bradley Manning, and the ongoing refusal to release the last British resident prisoner at Guantanamo, Shaker Aamer, who is also on a hunger strike to protest the conditions he is held under.
As thousands muster at protests across the country, such as the Occupy Wall Street protests covered here at The Dissenter, in the deepest, darkest holes of misery this country people are fighting with their lives for basic humanity and just treatment by a system that treats its victims — whether they are prisoners, or whether they are impoverished unemployed, thrown on the trash heap by financiers and indifferent politicians — with indifference at best, or sadistic animus at worst.
The prisoners cannot win their battle without public support. The public must see that the fate of the men and women thrown into American prisons is part of their own struggle, as the methods and attitudes fostered by the prison establishment are turned increasingly on the U.S. population as a whole, just as surveillance, mass round-ups, torture, and economic shock treatment has metastasized from imperialist foreign policy to a domestic program of immiserating working Americans to pay for Wall Street’s follies and the Pentagon’s wars.



24 Comments

Thank you for keeping us up to date on these issues. The long term incarcerated for possession of MJ is something that must be addressed.
The solitary confinement is torture and has deep psychological effects on humans.
This system is a Wall Street profit center. End it.
Thanks, Jeff! There has been absolutely nothing about this in any media that I’ve seen, mainstream or otherwise. If it were 12,000 Koch/Birch Tea Party Corporatists doing this, it would be the lead story on every TV news program for weeks on end.
Sounds like it would be wise to do whatever necessary to stay out of California prisons.
It’s beginning to look a lot like the 60s. Prisoners organized about their grievances back then, and today prisoners’ conditions are worse than then, as near as I can tell.
Then there’s prison rape, which is considered so acceptable by PTB that it is often used as an intimidation tactic on TV programs like L&O.
I’ve been upset about prisons at least since I heard about the privatization move. And only then bc that’s when it hit my radar screen.
If O has his way, there will be no more prisons. Only missile equipped drones.
Did you enjoy book salon?
I am betting yoo thinks torture in this case is justifiable and legal
Oh, I did. (wink)
I really liked the information that I gathered in between my questions being answered by another question. I know that is how they facilitate the workshops, but Dayyy Ummm! When out promoting your book, please take time to respond. I especially enjoyed your participation. As always, there are a few hard truth seekers in the Salons. You did good, Friend. Mighty Good!
Sorry for the delay in response. I’ve been poking in and out of the occupy thread.
“I have two words for you, Predator Drones, you will never see it coming, you think I’m joking …” President Barack Obama, smiling, with laughter in the background (or foreground – for the “looking forward” set …)
What a mensch, eh, eCAHN?
This is “the lesser evil”?
Excellent post, Jeff, a most-critical subject for America’s “humanity” to confront …
How many moral “strikes” does it take for a nation to forfeit its right to exist and become an existential threat to all life, deceny, and genuine human “progress”?
DW
I’ll second that, PP.
eCAHN is absolutely tremendous on the Book Salons!
And your questions deserved more than they got, PP.
Got there late, so I only got one question in …
DW
Yeah, I got really tired of Qs in response to Qs. I understand the methodology, but they carried it to an extreme that grew old. Think I left about half hour bef it was over.
Life is short. Authors have found out stuff I want to know by dint of their hard work. I don’t want to have to worm it out of them on the pretense that I’ll learn it better if I figure it out for myself.
Thanks for keeping the spotlight on this form of torture by authorities in the U.S.
Kudos to the prisoners for managing to organize their hunger strikes.
What useful things can ordinary citizens do?
U.S. IS an existential threat to millions & millions & millions. 4 million in VN, over a million in Iraq. No one’s counting in Afghanistan or Libya (Has U.S. already killed more people in Libya in months than Gaddafi killed in 4 decades? Enquiring minds….)
Oh, it’s just math, eCAHN, didn’t ya get the memo?
;~DW
I don’t like people being held in isolation but what is the solution to gang activity, which endangers everyone in the prison?
Well, when it comes to use of isolation on prisoners, it is not just Yoo. As I’ve repeatedly pointed out, joined by CCR, PHR, and others, the current Army Field Manual on Human Intelligence gathering (interrogation) — the manual endorsed by both the Obama administration and Congress as the Bible for military and CIA interrogations — legitimizes the use of isolation for up to 30 days, renewable after that, for prisoners deemed “unlawful enemy combatants.” (See Appendix M of the AFM.) Of course, at both Guantanamo and Bagram, as well as other U.S. military prison sites, such terms of solitary confinement have been known to be measured not in months, but in years.
Isolation is very effective in breaking down a person’s personality and debilitating them. It is a form of sensory deprivation, and it is definitely torture — the favorite form of torture, btw, of the old KGB, now used extensively by the latter’s old nemesis, and now we might say, inheritor.
What is the fundamental problem(s) which spurs the creation of gangs in prisons? Do gangs have anything to do with self-protection from predatory guards and humans turned into animals by inhumane conditions? Those are some of the items that go into gang formation on the outside world. One could start by addressing those issues and seeing whether gangs persist. And if they do, devise a Plan B.
Well the fundamental problem is that many of those incarcerated were in gangs before they were locked up so they see it as part of their lifestyle. But inside prison, non gang members have nowhere to go to escape the gang violence.
The prisoners and their supporters are asking people to “to pressure Governor Brown to ensure the CDCR implement the changes set forth in the prisoners’ five core demands and that the CDCR cease ALL retaliation on hunger strikers. Click here for phone numbers & a sample script.”
Yes, it’s absolutely critical that we provide better conditions for the leaders of the Mexican Mafia, the Aryan Brotherhood, MS-13, Crips, Bloods, etc. It’s critical that we end practices that segregate out from the general population those who assault, stab, molest, and kill other inmates and staff. We must remember that none of these people are psychopaths or sociopaths, none have other mental illnesses, and they’re all just great folks that we would be happy to have over as holiday house guests.
I mean, seriously, how do you incarcerate and control prisoners with no conscience, no empathy, and no sense of self-control? If you can’t impose draconian penalties, what mechanism do you have to try to maintain any semblance of order in the general population?
As for the bad food: isn’t this a cost issue? Maybe we could afford better food if we weren’t paying $100K annual pensions to ex-guards who retired at 55?
Anybody who thinks these prisoners in the SHU or Ad-Seg are just poor misunderstood political prisoners should watch a few episodes of LOCK UP.
in another life, i knew a man called ni**er boyd. sentenced to a ten year flop for attempted bank robbery, he forfeited all of his good time during the first six months of incarceration for verbally disrespecting the guards. after spending six/eight in segregation&isolation, aka the bomb shelter, boyd’s good time was restored and he was released. within a month, he was shot and killed during an attempted bank robbery.
was ni**er boyd insane before spending six years and eight months in isolation, with only the occasional death row inmate for contact? (cop contact with boyd was minimal because he was a poo and pee flinger.) or, did the isolation drive him nuts?
yes.
on the other hand, did the village idiot, wrongly convicted for selling beer to college students, and sentenced to a two year flop, go crazy because he was absolutely innocent and imprisoned, or because he spent his entire sentence in the bomb shelter.
yes.
and, did the man wrongly sentenced to five years for rape flip out?
no. but, he kept himself isolated from the general population, didn’t get tagged, and was paroled early.
then, there was the black box. very rarely used because a week in the box would drive most to radically meek submission or spontaneous acts of agression while a month long confinement assured a transfer to the state cackle factory for an interminable period of therapy.
finally, during my time, we were actually guilty of real crimes. rehabilitation was promoted and often successful. today, behavior crimes swell prison populations for profit. it is a positive feedback system that will eventually fail.
peas!