Shocking video continues to circulate of UC Davis students being pepper sprayed by riot police yesterday. I wrote about the police violence and the calls for the UC Davis chancellor to resign.
What is worth adding is the fact that students won. There is video showing riot police leaving the scene. Students remained. Some took down their tents. It does not appear the camp remained on the main quad area but police did not arrest everybody who gathered to bear witness to the brutality.
The brutality should not be what defines any occupation so here is why the UC Davis students feel they must “occupy”:
We’re protesting for the most basic of things, to declare our existence and relevance in the political order, to remind the country and ourselves that we own this place, that we own the problems of this place, and that we have the responsibility as citizens to engage and make things right.
Oh, the anarchy of young people taking responsibility for problems they didn’t create… Obviously the university needed to subdue this before it turned into a riot of discussions about what this country needs to do next to do better for its citizens…
Additionally, there is news of a memo from a lobbying firm being circulated. Huffington Post reports on this memo, which includes details on how to undermine the Occupy movement.
Firedoglake’s premier live blog continues. I’m headed to Occupy Maine. Post more updates here soon.
LIVE STREAM OF OCCUPY OAKLAND #N19 DEMONSTRATIONS
12:03 AM Peaceful and unusually calm. There are photos of police being circulated but it does not look like they are amassing around the new camp. Occupy Oakland is calling on people to come help defend the camp in case something happens.
10:45 PM Major action unfolding in Oakland —
@IntifadaTent posts this photo

Occupy Oakland is trying to establish a camp at 19th & Telegraph. Mayor Jean Quan has said this will not be permitted.
Thousands have been out marching for a November 19 day of action in Oakland.
6:20 PM Nicholas Kristof thinks Occupy Wall Street needs to keep occupying the agenda. It is a pretty good op-ed. The most valuable section is the following (and has nothing to do with what Kristof thinks the movement should do):
A new study by Michael I. Norton of Harvard Business School and Dan Ariely of Duke University polled Americans about what wealth distribution would be optimal. People across the board thought that the richest 20 percent of Americans should control about one-third of the nation’s wealth, and the poorest 20 percent about one-tenth.
In fact, the richest 20 percent of Americans own more than 80 percent of the country’s wealth. And the poorest 20 percent own one-tenth of 1 percent.
6:11 PM Nicolaus Mills for The Guardian puts the eviction of Occupy Wall Street into historical context comparing it to the attack on the Bonus Army in 1932. It is a fair comparison. But, the best part of Mills article is the final paragraph, which doesn’t have all that much to do with the history of the Bonus Army.
As the weather gets colder and the protesters figure out ways to get through the night without the sleeping bags and tents now banned from Zuccotti Park, it is the extraordinary care they have taken to welcome the mentally ill and the homeless drawn to their site that poses their greatest problem. Without either the power to tax or to build homeless shelters, Occupy Wall Street has taken upon itself to be more compassionate than the city.
5:59 PM Now, occupiers in Franklin School in Washington, DC, being arrested. (h/t TarheelDem)

5:53 PM Occupy San Jose in front of the mayor’s house after being kicked off public property – photo
5:41 PM National Lawyers Guild contends the rules Brookfield Properties has established for Liberty (Zuccotti) Park are illegal:
We believe that police are imposing limitations on the rights of the former occupiers of Liberty Park (aka Zuccotti Park) that exceed the Court’s Order as well as the concerns that the City expressed in the papers it submitted to the Court. While we would raise these matters in formal proceedings, it is possible that we can avoid additional burdens on the Court and the parties if we could all confer about these matters.
The letter goes on to cite the following as problematic: NYPD’s creation of a “frozen zone” around the park, limiting public access; NYPD and Brookfield Properties’ warrantless and unreasonable searches of people and property; police prevention protesters from lying down; police prohibition of sleeping bags from entering park; police prohibition of food from the park; police prohibition on musical instruments in the park; police prohibition on books into the park and the seizure or destruction of property without a written warrant or constitutionally significant notice and opportunity to be heard.
5:30 PM Couple thousand people at Occupy Oakland protests right now. Watch the live stream, which was just embedded in the blog.
5:29 PM Picture of lawn in front of Oakland City Hall that @Fara1 reports was flooded to keep Occupy Oakland away
5:27 PM City of Oakland prepares to obstruct Occupy Oakland from setting up another encampment tonight
5:19 PM Occupy Wall Street participants who tried to pick up property seized by NYPD during the eviction are finding their property was likely destroyed.
4:20 PM Chancellor Katehi creates task force to review pepper-spraying of UC Davis students
4:19 PM A group inspired by Occupy DC has taken over Franklin School, a four-story vacant building.
4:11 PM In the middle of the day, police have come to evict parts of Occupy SF (San Francisco). The police are at 101 Market & Justin Herman Plaza. Occupy SF is urging people in the area to come down and support. They especially need citizen journalists to come down and livestream the action.
4:09 PM Account from retired New York Supreme Court Judge Karen Smith, who was working as a legal observer after the raids on Liberty Park last Tuesday:
I’m standing there, some African-American woman goes up to a police officer and says, ‘I need to get in. My daughter’s there. I want to know if she’s OK.’ And he said, ‘Move on, lady.’ And they kept pushing with their sticks, pushing back. And she was crying. And all of a sudden, out of nowhere, he throws her to the ground and starts hitting her in the head,” says Smith. “I walk over, and I say, ‘Look, cuff her if she’s done something, but you don’t need to do that.’ And he said, ‘Lady, do you want to get arrested?’ And I said, ‘Do you see my hat? I’m here as a legal observer.’ He said, ‘You want to get arrested?’ And he pushed me up against the wall.
4:06 PM More than 3,900 have signed a petition that calls for Chancellor Katehi of UC Davis to resign after she allowed riot police to pepper spray UC Davis students yesterday.
4:04 PM Chris Hayes’ report on the lobbying firm memo. It indicates concern that OWS might find common cause with citizens that have identified themselves as “Tea Partiers”:
…Well-known Wall Street companies stand at the nexus of where OWS protestors and the Tea Party overlap on angered populism,” the memo says. “…This combination has the potential to be explosive later in the year when media reports cover the next round of bonuses and contrast it with stories of millions of Americans making do with less this holiday season…
4:02 PM Thank you to all those who have been posting comments on this post and adding updates. I will now add some items.



154 Comments

Thanks for the coverage, Kevin. Thanks for providing the venue every day for updates.
And most of all, thanks so much for what you’re doing at local Occupations around the country.
That made me tear up a bit. What an excellent quote.
Aweseome statement
Thank you, Kevin, for all your tireless work in daily keeping us informed and a part of this transformational moment.
I agree completely with Kris and Scarecrow, regarding the statement of purpose and intent so eloquently shared with all of us by the UC Davis students … this is what citizen leadership in a democracy is, and must be, all about.
DW
The “lobbying firm” of Clark, Lytle, Geduldig, (&) Cranford, needs to be held, squirming as they will, as they should, in the bright light of constant and unrelenting exposure.
They deserve to forever live in infamy, as their actions are an unforgivable assualt upon justice, upon freedom, upon liberty and upon human dignity.
No doubt, President Obama and all of the rest of the political class (which includes the media) hold these anti-democratic thugs, this “lobbying firm” to be very astute, respectable, and doing nothing that is “illegal” … however, as has been said recently, in another regard … there is also the central question of moral responsibility.
DW
More info on the memo from Up
Sounds like the memo is a really, really expensive rehash of old R tactics that may not work this time around. Leaderless and without demands, occupy is a slippery movement that’s difficult to slime.
Thank you for that link, ysd.
CLG&C need all the noteriety they can get! Pronto!
American Bankers Association?
Right … too big to fail, too big to nail, too big to go to jail …
Mebbe not … even if the political class continues to say that all of these despoilers and thugs are doing noting “illegal”.
Would you care to say that again, Barack Obama, when you return to the National Security State “Homeland”, after establishing a few more military bases for your precious drones and pimping for the American empire?
What a sniveling and greedy bunch of gold-plated cowards presume to rule us!
DW
Assuming it’s appropriate to post about Tahrir here as well as occupy. One and the same, right?
More on Egypt
_
Thankfully, Scott Olsen is the only seriously injured in US at occupy. It could be so much worse.
Excerpt from California Universitywide Police Policies and Procedures (Jan 7, 2011):
“812. Only authorized personnel may posses and maintain department issued oleoresin capsicum spray. Chemical agents are weapons used to minimize the potential for injury to officers, offenders, or other persons. They should be used only in situations where such force reasonably appears justified and necessary.”
How do several people, sitting on the ground with arms locked and with their heads bowed, constitute a situation “where such [chemical weapons] reasonably appears justified and necessary”?
Pic of rowd at Zuccotti today.
Their website:
http://www.clarklytlegeduldig.com/
Please click on the “Client” tab. It’s a must!
Yes, and what constituted reason for such “chemical weapons” to be forced down throats?
That is why I say it was clearly attempted MURDER!
Check out the tail end of yesterday’s liveblog for some interesting links and information that I put up this afternoon.
A link to a Xeni Jardin piece on Boing Boing has the pdf of the memo.
Occupy Long Beach CA on walking tour of small local businesses
http://police.ucdavis.edu/contact-info
above is link to UC Davis police – let them know what you think!
CBS New York: OWS Protesters To Get Thanksgiving Dinner Courtesy Of NYC Chef
Tarheel,
Thanks for this one too!
The police officers in my state are probably very jealous.
Budgetmeister Rahm at work:
Rahm’s CFD in action
My guess is a Lt in your state gets about half of that.
Occupy Bloomington IN: Hoosier Raging Grannies sing at a fundraiser for the homeless at Peoples Park
I know that’s a rhetorical question, but I’ll answer anyway. It doesn’t.
Holy crap. Course, isn’t the starting salary for recruits in Oakland 72K?
I have been searching for standards for police use of chemicals and equipment (including those batons), and I’m just not coming up with much. See the UC manual link I found above. Maybe it’s just that my search criteria are not sharp enough. I did find this one article relative to the subject, though it’s a few years old.
It seems when you have the means to do harm to US citizens, there should be some national, standardized policies and procedures to guide police officers in the appropriate use of those means (including for the protection of the police officers themselves). Lacking such standards, such as “Do no harm” which guides medical and health care practices, it’s no wonder things get way out of hand out there.
UC Davis Chancellor issues a new memo which states she is setting up a “Task Force”.
Here’s something, but not sure it applies to the poh-lice.
There is a Legal Liability and Risk Management Institute article link on yesterday’s liveblog that discusses pepper-spray.
It’s been coming…
Oh, many thanks, TarheelDem. I will check it out.
Jeeze. 2 p.m. Oakland action today. I guess they thought the best time to raid was when the march was gearing up. Divide and conquer? Fuel the 2 p.m. march and let it burn out today? Interesting timing.
I didn’t find the link over on the previous post, TarheelDem (my fault! — not yours), but you provided me with enough info that I found the thing easily through a search, and, boy, is it good!
Here’s the article, citing several major court cases (including the Humboldt County (CA) sheriffs applying pepper-spray with a Q-tip directly to the eyes of protestors (who could ever forget that one?):
http://www.llrmi.com/articles/legal_update/pepperspray.shtml
Hopefully, several interested people will copy this article for quick reference in the future.
Many, many thanks, TarHeelDem! You got quite a memory, my friend.
There was another protester/vet in Oakland who lost his spleen.
We are the 99% Occupy Levittown 11/17/11
Awesome.
Yep. Forgot about him.
Occupy Fargo-Moorhead “Billionaires for Banks” Protest
Occupy Bloomington IN: Radical cheerleaders at Peoples Park fundraiser for homeless!
Update from SR Occupy. Since the city required permits for tents and limited the permits to 54 to be posted outside the tend with the name and photograph of the permitholder (!!), the homeless who joined the camp are now legally camping in tents. I’m thinking the city’s plan backfired. There were around 150 tents previously, so the campers are fewer, but they are the most needy.
Occupy Tulsa occupies Wall Mart
This is how you do a flash mob action without arrests. Excellent.
Number the tents and the homeless have an address. With an address, USPS can deliver mail there…..
UC Davis Faculty Assoc, calls for Chancellor to resign.
http://ucdfa.org/
LOL!
Occupy Wall St – The Revolution Is Love
RT:
Occupy Ft. Benning: School of Americas protest (pic from Occupy Atlanta)
Occupy Canton OH: Right to Work
Occupy San Jose: Occupying the mayor’s driveway
Texas squatter claims $330,000 house, police can’t remove him
Terrible to see anyone hurt. But when they say they want to “own these problems” and “take responsibility”, what exactly are their proposals and solutions? I’ve seen nothing more than chanting and demonstrations without any real constructive ideas.
That’s because the press doesn’t cover the general assemblies. Or the task force groups that are working on solutions. But they are available to participate in in most localities across America now.
Flash mob of a thousand or so at Occupy Oakland
What an inspiring letter! Thanks for the link. Nathan Brown is my new hero.
Great, so you know what solutions these people have proposed? I see you are very active on these blogs. Would you let me know what those solutions are? I would like to write a letter to me congressmen.
Thanks!
Maybe you need to check in with the folks who are in your area as to what solutions they want to see. You know, participate in the process before you write a Congressman who is not likely to treat your letter with attention unless there is a hefty check enclosed with it.
Thanks. I have done that here in Atlanta as I pass by woodruff park on my way to my job. I never see any concrete demands. It is always “down with this” or “do away with that” but never “here’s what we want to see instead and here’s how to get there”. It’s all very nebulous.
I frankly think that’s the downfall of this movement. There are actually many people in the general assemblies up in new york who are totally against offering any specific demands.
Do I believe there needs to be change? Yes. But does OWS know what that change should be? No.
Would you vote for a candidate who said he or she was totally against the system in place today but not only offers no specifics of what he or she would do when in office but clearly did not know more than the party line of “No”?
Occupy Des Moines makes the news
The striking thing about the memo is there is no apology, no horror. There is the coldness of beaurocratic gibberish. There’s a place on the website to email recommendations to the task force she’s created. I was lavish in my calling for dismissals and charges being brought all around for assault and ordering assault.
Separately, the comment I made on her blog has been in moderation all day.
Since you are in Atlanta, you need to check their web site, Occupy Atlanta. The first place to start to answer some of your questions is in the General Assembly Guide (which is about the ground rules of the process) and the General Assembly minutes of discussions. It is helpful to read from the earliest minutes in chronological order to get a sense of where the group is going.
The Occupy Wall Street movement is more about a process than a predefined agenda of demands. The process is one of identifying issues; seeing how they fit together, getting educated on the buzzwords, jargon, and ideas that are involved in an area of concern; developing small-scale, inexpensive solutions to test out solution ideas. In the midst of this are specific immediate direct actions focused on different specific demands. For example, an action of protest at Bank of America is for Bank of America to stop sucking money out of the pockets of the 99% to line the pockets of the 1%. Also to stop buying members of Congress so that they can do that under the color of law.
A protest against foreclosure is to highlight the fact that at the loan origination information provided, the servicing of the loan, the bundling of mortgages into derivative securities, the terms agreement process, and the foreclosure process, there have been many instances of fraud by those corporations engaged in the mortgage industry. And that although taxpayers bailed out the banks on generous terms, negotiations of terms to avoid foreclosure and eviction on the part of homeowners has been one of inflexible rules, forcing hundreds of thousands of people nationwide out of their homes. A protest at a particular house is a demand that the sheriff, the mortgage holders, the foreclosing agent, and any intermediaries (such as Fannie Mae) treat the family as human beings and try to work out an adjustment of terms that allows them to keep their home.
A protest at a Verizon location is a demand for Verizon to negotiate in good faith with the union Communications Workers of America.
A protest at Georgia State University is a demand that the state better fund higher education to permit students to attend colleges without taking out monstrous student loans to cover ever higher tuition fees.
Most folks are clear that the economy is broken globally, that politics in Washington (if not at all levels of government) is in grid lock, and that the extraordinary influence of corporate money in politics keeps it that way. And that the elites no longer know what they are doing besides sucking huge salaries and capital gains out of the system. And most folks understand that this is going to be a complicated thing for ordinary people to sort out. The Occupy Wall Street movement is a process for sorting this out.
As for the candidates with a party line of “No”, we have them in power right now, wanting to drown government as an institution in the bathtub.
Occupy Lexington KY: I learned not to be greedy in preschool
Wow!
Rev. Neal Jones at Common Ground
Occupy Columbia livestreamed this conference and their participation in it today. This speech by Rev. Neal Jones, of the Columbia Unitarian-Universalist Congregation of Columbia is outstanding. His short history of the themes of race and class in South Carolina politics is a gem.
Peasant Party, this one’s for you.
Occupy Missoula MT prepares for winter with a Korean-war vintage army tent
Great tent. Big enough for meetings. Good for them.
can -> ban (maybe?)
#OccupyLA Indigenous People’s Ceremony shared on the South lawn. We love and thank you!
Occupy Minneapolis livestreaming from inside an occupied foreclosed house
WTF?
Occupy Foreclosure
Occupy Portlant; Lunch at Peoples Park
Occupy UC Davis livestream from Surge II
Occupy Easton PA photo set
LS Occupy UC Davis
Crowd chanting to the chancellor, “Just walk home…just walk home…”
LS Occupy UC Davis
Occupy UC Davis got word that the chancellor was having a press conference in Surge II. They are outside protesting, but not preventing the chancellor from leaving.
LS Occupy UC Davis
“CNN is talking about UC-D right now”
LS Occupy UC Davis
The petition for asking for the chancellor’s resignation now has 12,000 signatures.
LS Occupy UC Davis
There is a human chain around the building.
LS Occupy UC Davis
Not a negotiation. The students are demanding the chancellor’s resignation from her $400K position.
You cannot petition the Lords Of Power, they only answer to a higher power, money.
LS Occupy UC Davis
“Whose university? Our university?”
Occupy UC Davis – human chain around building
LS – Occupy UC Davis
Crowd moving away from Surge II and reassembling away from the building.
LS – Occupy UC Davis
The students form two lines, sit on the ground, and are silent as the Chancellor walks out to her car, which is far away because of the number of students in the line.
LS – Occupy UC Davis
Chancellor walks through a very long silence and leaves. The students cheer. Then they start chanting “Katehi resign…Katehi resign” Then there is an announcement that there is free pizza and music to celebrate.
How wonderful!! How absolutely wonderful. Many, many thanks, TarheelDem!
The Rise of the Winter Occupation of Missoula photo set
The #occupyoakland marchers are going to banks and posting past due notices on their doors.
WHOOP! Whoop!
Thankye, Neighbor. HotDayyumm! That was good.
That is just Perfect. They can go back next week and put up Foreclosure notices!
Let’s hope she has the resignation up online tomorrow.
UC Davis Chancellor’s long walk to her car.
From “The cop group coordinating the Occupy crackdowns” (San Francisco Bay Guardian Online, by Shawn Gaynor, Nov. 18, 2011; my bold):
“Paramilitary Policing of Occupy Wall Street: Excessive Use of Force amidst the New Military Urbanism” (DemocracyNow.Org, Nov. 17, 2011)
More related pieces from DemocracyNow.Org.
Re Australia:
Re Albany, NY:
Re Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia:
“Malaysia starts war crimes hearing against Bush, Blair” (Presstv.IR, Nov. 19, 2011)
Just ran across this video and you gotta see it! It is not even recent!
Skip the ad:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jmzTqHOfVvE&feature=share
Kevin,
The more I hear the very important people say that OWS should be in DC it occurs to me that there is a purposeful media blackout for it. I think we should highlight it more.(Just a friendly suggestion.)
Thank you for that most important clip and link!
Interesting, but not terribly specific. Withdrawal from Iraq completely would put an additional 20,000 troops back in the US. So would any movement from a forward-deployed strategy. I think both of those are good things.
And how many of that number are National Guard (who the Bush administration called up for repeated tours) who will now be returning to civilian jobs but are still counted as military?
The fact that the Wall Street Media have seen fit not to report this even as a rumor to knock down shows how locked into certain narratives they have become.
I will say this again because it needs to be said. Every media outlet has an agenda. Al Jazeera is under the thumb (even more so now) of the Qatar royal family. PressTV is the Voice of America counterpart of the Iranian government. Russia today is controlled by the Russian government. This report is vague enough not to have a lot of real substance and it carries a lot of presumption. Sorta like the Wall Street Media’s breathless reporting of Iran’s nuclear intentions.
Thinking worse case scenarios to be true is what suckered the US public into supporting the Iraq War.
Keep a lookout for what specific multi-sourced factual report is behind this story.
I have seen the military used as police in this country. To control the riots (and they were plain outrage mindlessly acted out) after the assassination of Martin Luther King. I remember very vividly the ragtop military trucks of the 82nd Airborne rolling through one of the nicer high-rise/rowhouse neighborhoods of Baltimore, troops standing on the boards and leaning back into the canvas with their rifles at the ready. For four or five days, Baltimore was an militarily occupied city.
Quinn Norton, Wired: Anonymous Hacks Back at Cybercrime Investigators
A nice euphemism, “cybercrime investigators”. Who do they serve? Who do they protect?
More on the “antisec” Anonymous statement:
Occupy Collin County (TX): Anonymous V. United States Government: Latest Threat and “Most Important One in History”
FWIW
Wikipedia: Nonviolent Resistance
Fascinating historical outline.
UC Davis Chancellor Katehi walks to her car
The walk of shame. Look at her stoic expression.
WHOOP!
I don’t know anything about the techie stuff, but Jesus if they can help I’m so for it!
Thanks so much for this link. PERF is very interesting. Here’s their report on their effort to come up with guidelines and standards for use of tasers. This particular effort of theirs was funded by the DOJ, as you can see.
(I’m still obsessing on the lack of national standards for the use of weapons against US citizens by law enforcement. We’re still in the Wild West mode, it seems.)
Occupy Movement URGENT Message Look out for Staged Riots!
Good review of primarily Canadian incidents.
Portland Bike Cop
And from Occupy Davis (the separate community occupation):
Kevin has a new post up
http://dissenter.firedoglake.com/2011/11/20/live-blog-for-occupy-movement-occupy-oakland-sets-up-a-new-camp/
I loved the reporter asking her, near the end, “Do you still feel threatened by the students?” Priceless.
Taking the opportunity to thank you, TD, and the rest of he update team, for all your HEROIC efforts in reporting and illuminating the ongoing events. Sending all you guys a huge psychic hug. Each one of you is a hero of the revolution, IMO.
Bring that stuff and come upstairs with us.
Way late on here, but had to respond to this – extremely interesting factoid, mzchief. I am not happy with the US Military flexing its muscles down under, and maybe Malaysia isn’t happy either.
A belated “Amen” to that.
Hey folks I was away for two days and could read all the events on my phone but I seemed to have blockage of service when I tried to post.
First, I find the “chemical waterboarding” a apt description. However, Kevin, it might be worth researching the CA laws on rape. In my state, the definition states that any forced entry of a body orifice with any item used by perpetrator or body part of the perpetrator is rape.
In my observation, those that had their mouths forced open and a canister put in or directly in front of the mouth opening and pepper spray forced into their mouths/bodies, were raped.