
Screen shot from Emad Burnat’s documentary, “5 Broken Cameras”
Emad Burnat is the Palestinian director of the Oscar-nominated documentary, “5 Broken Cameras.” He is the first Palestinian to be nominated for an Academy Award.
He traveled to the United States this week because the Academy Awards ceremony is this weekend. It is common for nominees to be in attendance. But on Tuesday night, US Immigration & Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers detained and held him at the Los Angeles International Airport. They threatened to send him back to Palestine before the ceremony.
Burnat came with his wife and eight year-old son. On HuffPost Live, he described being put in a holding area with Africans and Asians. He tried to explain he was an Oscar nominee and that he had documents on his iPhone that would confirm his identity. The officers said they didn’t care. They needed more documents and more papers and, if he didn’t give them the documents, he would be sent home.
The Palestinian filmmaker was to attend a dinner for documentary nominees hosted by filmmaker Michael Moore. Burnat contacted Moore for help. Moore contacted Academy officials, who contacted the president of the Academy, Howard Koch. Koch, according to Moore, contacted a firm in Los Angeles to get an immigration lawyer. Moore also contacted someone in Washington, DC, who might be able to ask the State Department to intervene.
Burnat told his son Jibril they were under arrest. He was upset because he did not expect this to happen in America.
ICE officers eventually released him after one and a half hours. He was told he and his family could be in Los Angeles for a week to attend the Oscars. Burnat reacted, “It’s nothing I’m not already used to,” he told me later. “When you live under occupation, with no rights, this is a daily occurrence.”
Burnat was not informed of why he was stopped. He had previously attended Moore’s film festival in Michigan when his film was shown. He was able to get into the US with no problem. However, the Israeli government would not allow him to fly out of Tel Aviv. He had to get to Amman, Jordan, to fly to the US.
This time, Moore said, he simply decided to go to Amman and not Tel Aviv, but he was hassled and kept for five or six hours at a checkpoint before he was allowed to pass through to catch his flight. Given that, it is highly likely the Israeli government is responsible in some way for Burnat being detained.
The incident is similar to what happened in May 2012, when a Pakistani student who had won an international award for a short film on US drone attacks in Pakistan was denied a visa.
Danish Qasim, director of The Other Side which won the Best Audience Award at the National Film Festival for Talented Youth in Washington, produced a film that revolved “around the idea of assessing social, psychological and economical affects of drones on the people in tribal areas of Pakistan.” According to the Pakistani newspaper, The Express Tribune, it identified ”the problems faced by families who have become victims of drone missiles, and it unearths the line of action which terrorist groups adopt to use victimized families for their vested interests.”
Qasim had his visa application rejected twice. The director concluded this had happened because, “If we got the visa then it would have been easy for us to frame our point of view in front of the other selected youth filmmakers. The film gained interest from the audience across the globe compelling festival administrators to give Audience Award to the film.” His views run counter to US government policy on drones so he had to be ideologically excluded from visiting the United States.
In the case of Burnat, Alive Mind Cinema describes his film as a “deeply personal, first-hand account of non-violent resistance” in a West Bank village threatened by Israeli settlements. It consists almost entirely of footage shot by Burnat.
The film opens with him laying out his five cameras. He says, “I’ve lived through so many experiences. They burn in my head like a hot flame. Pain and joy, fears and hope are all mixed together.” He is talking about what he has witnessed through each of his cameras, along with the injuries and pain he has endured when targeted, detained and shot at by Israeli soldiers when trying to record the experiences of Palestinians.
The footage in the documentary captures the brutality of Israeli soldiers. It shows the thuggish nature of settlers, who beat up Palestinians that challenge their seizure of Palestinian land.
The images directly undermine Israeli government policy toward Palestinians, which the US government unapologetically and vehemently supports. For that reason, he was on a list of people to be deported and stopped from visiting the US. The last thing the government of this country wants is for people like Burnat to share their experiences with Americans. That might lead to Americans questioning US support for Israeli policies.
The administration of George W. Bush was notorious for denying visas to people, whose views were in direct conflict with American foreign policy. Tariq Ramadan, an Islamic intellectual hired by the University of Notre Dame, had his visa canceled under the Patriot Act and, in 2006, the State Department tried to cast him as a “material supporter of terrorism.” In 2005, Dora Maria Tellez, a Sandinista revolutionary who helped to overthrow dictator Anastasio Somoza, was denied entry to take up a post as a Harvard professor. The State Department alleged she had been involved in “terrorism.” Sixty-one Cuban scholars sought to attend the Latin American Studies Association’s “international congress” in Las Vegas in October 2004. They were told letting them enter would be “detrimental to the interests of the United States.”
In June 2006, the Marxist Greek professor John Milos, who was teaching political economy and the history of economic thought at the National Technical University in Athens, was denied entry to present a paper on “How Class Works” at a conference at the State University of New York. He had a visa that he had used five times and it did not expire until November. But, when he tried to enter to attend the conference, he was told there were “technical problems” with his visa. Then, he was interrogated at JFK airport and asked about his views and political involvement in Greece. His visa was canceled and he was sent back to Greece. In October 2006, Adam Habib, the professor of political science at the University of KwaZulu-Natal and a known South African political commentator, was detained at a New York airport. His visa was revoked. He was sent back to South Africa.
The next year, in April 2007, Riyadh Lafta, a prominent Iraqi professor of medicine at Al-Mustansiriya University in Baghdad, Iraq, was blocked from giving a lecture at the University of Washington and working on a research project on “increased rates of cancer among children in southern Iraq” His visa was believed to have been denied because he was “one of the principal authors of an October 2006 article in the British medical journal, The Lancet,” that produced a “controversy” when it estimated “more than 650,000 Iraqis” had been killed by the US invasion of Iraq.
Despite the fact that the State Department under Obama lifted the curb against Ramadan and Habib in 2010, individuals with views the US government considers dangerous are still being detained or denied visas. In February 2011, founding member of the Palestinian Civil Society Boycott, Divestment, Sanction (BDS) campaign, Omar Barghouti, was denied entry to tour the US for the release of a book on his work. In March 2011, Afghan women’s rights activist Malalai Joya, a fierce critic of the Afghanistan war, planned to go on a US speaking tour and was denied a travel visa. The US embassy officer in Afghanistan said she was denied because she is “unemployed” and “lives underground.”
A Kurdish human rights advocate Kerem Yildz had trouble getting his visa approved in 2011. Pakistani lawyer Shahzad Akbar, who has challenged and filed lawsuits against CIA drone strikes in Pakistan, was not granted a visa in 2011 when he wanted to attend a human rights conference at the Columbia University law school in New York City. [He was, after protests from CODEPINK and others, allowed to attend a drone summit in April 2012.] And, in October 2012, Pakistani political leader Imran Khan, an outspoken critic of US drone strikes, was taken off an international flight from Canada to New York and detained and interrogated by ICE about his views on drones. He missed a fundraising lunch in New York City he had hoped to attend.
People like Burnat come to the United States or travel long distances to accept awards because they want to share their experiences and views with people who do not live in their country and suffer the repression or injustices they live through daily. Burnat said in an interview, “Most people don’t know what’s happening in Palestine. They hear about it and see it on the news, but they don’t know the truth.” That is why Burnat edited the footage and his personal story and produced a film. It is also why ICE officers stopped him at the airport. The truth he brings to the United States poses a threat to the foreign policy agenda of the United States.
Here is Burnat and Moore on HuffPost Live:



22 Comments

Just imagine if Burnat didn’t have people like Moore in his corner. I was awake last night and saw as Moore tweeted about it. I hope clowns like Jeffrey Goldberg are happy.
On NPR radio, at 5 pm, today, they did a piece on his film. They presented the settlers’ side of the story. {The piece was pretty pro Israel.} Not one mention of his detainment at the airport!
I am pretty certain, based on what happened at the checkpoint when he was trying to get to Amman, that the Israeli government notified the US government Burnat was traveling to the US for the Oscars. They were likely urged by Israel to have him deported so he could not attend the awards ceremony.
Scumbags…… Pathetic scumbags, when the oppressed become the oppressor. I recall a conversation with a German man who was Jewish. He was a holocaust survivor. It was after the Red Sox won game six on the way to winning the World Series, some years back. I asked if he had seen the game. His response was, “no.” “I don’t care about baseball.” ” I’m just happy to be alive.” That is when I saw the tattooed numbers on his forearm. I asked if he was a death camp survivor. “Yes,” was his response. He then told me how he was the lone survivor of his family, and went to Israel. I asked when he came to to America and why. He stated he came to America in the early 1962. That he could no longer, as a holocaust survivor stay in Israel, because, ” the oppressed are now the oppressors.” I will take this memory to my grave, as an American half German. Sad reality is that your story today, supports his assertion. I support Israel. I do not support or condone the actions of Fuck-heads…. In this instance ICE and Israel are being consummate misguided pathetic fuck heads……
Makes me ashamed of America. ICE seems out of control.
Blacklisted, but not totally blacklisted. Once Burnat boarded the plane out of Jordan and landed in the US, Oilbomber and Israel wanted him deported (to shut him up!). But Burnat had a solid connection with that rabble rouser Michael Moore so ICE had to let him in at that point.
Moore (“reluctant” Obama supporter) would raise holy hell, otherwise.
Oilbomber and Israel would like to make a lot of people go away (and they do).
Wow—always so pathetic, disgusting and comical to watch a brain-dead elephant show how terrified it is of a mouse that can roar.
“He was upset because he did not expect this to happen in America.”
“It’s nothing I’m not already used to,” he told me later. “When you live under occupation, with no rights, this is a daily occurrence.”
Because America hasn’t been the Land of the Free since Saint Ron Reagan’s days. And since G W Bush’s days’ it’s been completely transformed into a fascist police-state, complete with ID card checks on the interstate highways. The only ‘rights’ we have left are the ones the Koch Brothers haven’t ordered Obama to take away … yet.
Welcome to Amerika. Land of Israeli controlled bullshit, home of cowardly alphabet soop agency’s who bend to Israeli wishes.
This whole “detainment” as retaliation against those who are deemed a political threat to the powers that be is getting to the point of Nazi Germany.
“Your papers please..or else”. Total, unadulterated bullshit. Amerika makes me vomit now.
ICE out of control ? That assumption is the exact opposite of mine .I see Big Brother in control of everything and ICE doing its mission with usual ham-handed execution .
This is all flipping B.S.
Chairman and CEO of the Motion Picture Association of America is former SENATOR Chris DODD. He is capable of directly calling President Obama on the cell phone and, if he wanted, he could have this Palestinian filmmaker released within seconds from ICE or, more importantly, could have made sure in advance that this kind of treatment does not happen.
Bottom line is this is just a way for JEWS and ISRAEL to show who controls America. Of course, they do. Look what they did to Mel Gibson. They made issue out of nothing and banished Mel just to teach a lesson that Jews run Hollywood. They have no way to control who gets voted for Oscar but they can make your life miserable in may ways if you are a Muslim/ Palestinian or someone who dare to say truth against Israel and Jews.
The only thing good coming out of this shameful incidence is maybe now this guy has found material to make another documentary because of this experience.
What has happened to the “flag this comment as inappropriate” tag? The state of Israel is an abomination, as this post and countless other data show, but it is not a matter of “the jews,” and comment #11 is offensive.
stories like this make me think the ‘holygobbledebook’ is a lesson in oppression, or simply a business plan.
‘five broken cameras’ is compelling.
peas!
I know two countries that desperately need to be bombed back to the stone age. One of them in is the middle east, the other north america.
Of course, religion is a lesson in oppression. Do not seek material wealth, leave that to the rich. They’ll all suffer in hell later while you get the Mansion after you’re dead.
Why would I want or need a Mansion after I’m dead ?
This is a great film about people, watch it if you can! We were very fortunate to have Emad Burnat and his family visit Traverse City this past summer. Five Broken Cameras was awarded Best Film at the Traverse City Film Festival, held here every summer.
Thanks to both Emad Burnat and Guy Davidi for telling this story so well.
I don’t take kindly to your anti-Semitism. And, yes, this talk about Jews does seem anti-Semitic to me.
I agree, Kevin, as I said @ 12.
Don’y know whether I loathe your comment or pity you more.
Al-Jazeera TV just ran this story. Burnat said that he was used to such treatment at home, but to get it here was “very strange.”
I was supposed to be replying to @ #11 in my comment above. Sorry.
I’ve made a helluva a lot of Jewish friends while working hard for Palestinian rights, and hard against the apartheid Zionist state. Many of the most articulate and courageous supporters of Palestinians, the rights of Arab women in various countries, and opponents to our neo-con and neo-lib policies are Jews, all around the world. Apartheid-supporting Zionists hate these Jewish heroes so much, they keep a rapidly growing list of them, so they can be harassed. About 30 of my friends are on it.
I’ve been watching this detainment-harassment episode unfold since Moore tweeted about it. Your compilation and commentary on it, Kevin, is the best yet.